There's nothing wrong with a swap partition on the RAID.  What I was
suggesting was maybe you were using SWAP on a hard partition which
perhaps overlapped with part of the physical volumes for the RAID.   I'm
not sure, but clearly it sounds like you have corruption showing up on
your LVM device.  Why that is the case is hard to say, but partition
table misconfiguration is certainly one of the possibilities.

Ubuntu is free distribution, which means best efforts support for bug
reports.  If you pay for commercial support (which Canonical may or may
not provide, but certainly companies like Red Hat, Novell, IBM, HP, all
provide), you'll get someone who will respond right away, and say, "You
know, this really doesn't like an e2fsprogs bug"; and help you determine
whether it's a hardware problem, or maybe a LVM device driver problem,
or maybe a user configuration problem.   To have someone who can do this
well and with a fast response time takes time, and money; training
someone who can diplomatically suggest that maybe the Problem Exists
Between Keyboard And Chair (PEBKAC) without truly pissing off the
customer is difficult, and you pay the really good people who can do OS
root cause problem determination a very good salary.

So here, when a bug report gets filed as an e2fsprogs bug, I as the
upstream volunteer will do a quick scan of the queue, see common themes,
and or things that are clearly bugs, and try to deal with them.
Ubuntu's bug scanning folks don't scan very frequently, and fair enough
--- this is a freebie service for them, and they are primarily focused
on making the distribution better, as opposed to making sure someone
isn't walking away from an expensive 7x24 support contract.

Regards,

-- 
Data corruption with ext3 in striped logical volume
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/100126
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to