On 9/11/26 06:40, Juerg Haefliger via ubuntu-devel wrote:
All,
Now that the linux-firmware split has landed in Noble, I'd like to tackle the
next firmware issue: HWE backports.
The problem at the moment is that backporting firmware to LTS releases for
their respective HWE kernels often negatively impacts users running the GA
kernel. Old kernel with new firmware is not a combination that firmware
vendors typically test. Firmware updates between Ubuntu releases have grown
significantly in recent years, resulting in larger backports and a higher
chance of regressions. This approach to firmware backports has long been a
thorn in the side of the SRU team, and rightly so. Just the recent backports
to Noble for the 7.0 HWE kernel introduced at least two AMD regressions for
6.9 kernel users :-(
To address this, I’d like to propose introducing linux-firmware-hwe (along
with HWE variants for all subpackages). HWE kernels would depend on
linux-firmware-hwe, which in turn would provide and break linux-firmware so
only one set of packages can be installed at a time.
This will prevent regressions for GA-only users. For systems that have both
GA and HWE kernels installed, all kernels will load the HWE firmwares,
meaning users might still encounter firmware-related issues when booting the
GA kernel. The only complete workaround for that scenario would be installing
both GA and HWE firmwares side-by-side in separate directories and pointing
the respective kernels to load from their own paths. However, that introduces
a whole new set of non-trivial challenges so I'm not considering this at this
moment.
I’d like to introduce this in Stonking first and then backport it to Resolute
before the first HWE kernel lands there.
I'd love to hear your feedback, suggestions, questions, comments, ...
Thanks
..Juerg
IIRC the kernel will look at /lib/firmware/`uname -r` before /lib/firmware/.
So how about a symlink building system? Bear with me.
* linux-firmware-hwe could put everything in /lib/firmware/hwe.
* linux-firmware-oem could put everything in /lib/firmware/oem.
* Then every HWE kernel package could ship a symlink for
/lib/firmware/`uname -r` -> /lib/firmware/hwe.
* Every OEM kernel package could ship a symlink for /lib/firmware/`uname
-r` -> /lib/firmware/oem.
"Generic" firmware would still be in the "regular" /lib/firmware/ directory.
--
ubuntu-devel mailing list
[email protected]
Modify settings or unsubscribe at:
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-devel