Informed distrusting democrats: The effects of citizen participation Ugandan constitution-making

Moehler, Devra Coren;

PhD Dissertation

UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN (2003)

 

In 1988, Uganda embarked on an innovative constitution-making process that involved extensive citizen participation. South Africa, Eritrea, Fiji, and Albania followed with analogous programs. Currently, reformers in other democratizing states are calling for participatory constitution-making as a constructive step towards building a democratic political culture. The Ugandan program provides a unique ‘natural experiment’ from which to observe the influence of participation on political attitudes, knowledge, and behavior.

 

This dissertation analyzes the effects of public participation in the Ugandan constitution-making process. Accounting for the possibility of reciprocal relationships, I test the hypotheses that participation fosters attachment to democratic principles, enhances feelings of civic competence, heightens trust in government, and builds support for the constitution. My research shows that participation in a new democracy can create �distrusting democrats�; citizens who are democratic in their attitudes but suspicious of their government institutions. I argue that participation affects trust by enhancing political knowledge and by altering the standards against which individuals judge their government. In developing democracies, participation gives citizens a new set of tools for evaluating their imperfectly performing institutions.

 

Furthermore, I demonstrate that participants can remain committed to the fundamental principles of the system even when they become dissatisfied with government performance. My results are based on: a national survey of 820 Ugandan citizens randomly sampled according to a multi-stage area sampling design; in-depth interviews with citizens in 11 of 45 districts; elite interviews; news analysis; and archival research. This dissertation contributes to the literature on democratization, constitution-making, political participation, and trust by highlighting the importance of institutional performance for predicting whether participation and civic awareness will enhance or diminish citizen faith in government. Add itionally, it encourages scholars to examine the content of the in messages that citizens are exposed to while participating.


Get a FREE online computer virus scan from McAfee when you click here. -------------------------------------------- This service is hosted on the Infocom network http://www.infocom.co.ug

Reply via email to