On 25/12/2023, 15:56:17, "Mitchell Southgate - 39D IT Services"
<[email protected]> wrote:
With the LOA I currently hold a /24 in 44.X.X.X range which is amprnet (amateur
radio / ham radio).
I am familiar with it and the arguments over if it should ever be routed
widely on
the internet from back in 1995 when I ran a (maybe the only) UK wormhole
(vpn) to tunnel
the UK back to UCSD.
I have had many discussions with carriers over the fact I cannot do ROA. They
still issue us
a LOA which some carriers accept and others do not.
If ROA are to be the only source of authority it is a flaw that they are
not availaible to all
that need them so LOA carry on being used to bypass them, though LOA
prove nothing (who checks
you didn't write it yourself) and are not evenly accepted.
The issue here is it treat as legacy space and as such I cannot control it in
ARIN
The fix is for ARIN to not exclude legacy if ROA are to be the only
mechanism, or
not have the RIR monopoly but that would persist alternative IRRs.
I can understand ARIN only wanting to provide hosted RPKI to full
members but
it should be possible for a legacy holder to run self hosted as that is
the price
of ARIN membership.
brandon
