Am 2000-06-16 um 11:42 h hat Antoine Leca geschrieben:
> should it be ,,deutsch'', or ,,Deutsch'', in such a context?

The context, if I remember correctly, was a list of countries,
so it should rather be "Deutschland" (with a capital "D",
cf. <http://www.ids-mannheim.de/grammis/reform/d3-1.html#P55>).

Now, the question still is, should it be "deutsch", or "Deutsch".
This, indeed, depends on the context.

If a sentence commences with that (ar indeed any other) word, it
is capitalized, as in "Deutsch",
cf. <http://www.ids-mannheim.de/grammis/reform/d2.html#P54>.
This also holds for headings and titels,
cf. <http://www.ids-mannheim.de/grammis/reform/d2.html#P53>,
even if a titel is quoted within a sentence,
cf. <http://www.ids-mannheim.de/grammis/reform/d2.html#53E1>.
This also holds for list items, as in the original example, cf. item 5
under <http://www.ids-mannheim.de/grammis/reform/d2.html#P54>.

In normal text, the spelling of language names is a bit tricky, as in
some cases they are considred adjectives (small initial), in other
cases nouns (capital initial). (It's the border-cases that render a
set of rules tricky; and natural languages seem to have plenty of those.)

- If the word is obviously used as a noun, it is capitalized, as in
  "Er spricht ein gut verst�ndliches Deutsch" (where "Deutsch" is the
  kernel of a full-fledged noun phrase, complete with article "ein"
  and attribute "gut verst�ndliches"), cf. item 1 under
  <http://www.ids-mannheim.de/grammis/reform/d3-2.html#P57>.

- If the word is used as an adjective, either attributive as in
  "Ich trinke deutsches Bier", or adverbial, as in "Ich rede deutsch
  mit dir", it is written with a small initial.

- Now the really tricky part are sentences such as
      "Sie sprechen deutsch miteinander" (= "They converse in German.") or
      "Er unterrichtet deutsch" (= "He delivers his lessons in German"),
  vs. "Sie sprechen Deutsch" (= "The speak German"), or
      "Er unterrichtet Deutsch" (= "He gives German lessons"),
  cf. <http://www.ids-mannheim.de/grammis/reform/d3-2.html#57E2>.

For more examples,
cf. <http://www.ids-mannheim.de/grammis/reform/wort-d.html>.

Ich hoffe, Sie verstehen diesen Absatz, auch wenn er deutsch geschrieben
ist, und k�nnen nun etwas besser Deutsch schreiben ;-)

Best wishes,
   Otto Stolz

Reply via email to