Martin J. Dürst wrote: > Well, the translation isn't perfect :-(. It translates > "Have you vomited?" to "あなたは嘔吐していますか?" > Apart from the unnecessary (in Japanese) subject, and the usually not > used question mark, it's present tense, corresponding to "Are you > vomiting?". I'm sure no doctor would have to ask this.
Doctors ask this kind of question all the time: "Are you coughing? Are you wheezing?" The clear intent of such a question is not so much "Are you now?" but rather "Have you been lately?" In any case, the language-challenged doctor-patient pair should reach common understanding fairly quickly. -- Doug Ewell | http://ewellic.org | Thornton, CO 🇺🇸

