I second Mike's recommendation that you review West Marine's discussion 
about batteries.  It's in the West Advisor (under the Advice & Articles 
tab, look under "Electrical" and then the article titled "Selecting a 
Marine Storage Battery."  URL here:  
http://www.westmarine.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/WestAdvisorView?langId=-1&storeId=11151&catalogId=10001&page=Selecting-a-Marine-Storage-Battery
 
I don't know from your post exactly what you need - you said you need to 
replace your starting batteries.  What you don't say is whether you have a 
separate deep-cycle battery bank for house use when your engines are off 
and you're not hooked up to shore power (lights, refrigeration, etc.)  If 
you do, then for your starting bank all you need is a standard 
automotive-style starting battery, the kind you can get at Costco, Sam's 
Club or Sears.  These batteries are designed to deliver a short burst of 
high power.  You'll kill them if you run them down, like using them for 
house loads over a weekend at anchor.  They're not built for deep 
discharges.  You don't need a "marine" battery for pure starting loads.  
 
If you have a separate bank that you use only for house loads, you need 
dedicated deep-cycle batteries.  These are designed to be drawn down 
substantially and recharged repeatedly - which is treatment that will kill 
an automotive (e.g., starting) battery.  Best price around Seattle that 
I've found on these is the Dyno brand at Fisheries.
 
If you use your batteries for both starting and house loads, then you need 
a dual-purpose battery, like the "marine" battery at Costco or other 
discounters.  West Marine sells dual-purpose batteries, too.  So does 
Fisheries Supply - and they might be more competitive than West.
 
On the battery chemistry debate, I weigh in heavily on the side of 
old-school flooded batteries.  Yes, AGM and gel-cel batteries are great and 
don't leak (although they do outgas and need to be vented like flooded 
batteries), but the cost difference is (to me) not worth their added 
benefits.  The only benefit I can see that I would like about AGM batteries 
is that they will accept a higher rate of charge acceptance (which 
translates to shorter charging - e.g., engine-running - times).  
 
A flooded deep cycle battery will accept a charge of approximately 25% of 
the amp-hour rating versus the AGM charge acceptance of about 40% - but 
this doesn't matter to me because I have a house bank of 2 8D batteries, 
which have an amp-hour rating of 255 each (510 both).  This means that my 
flooded batteries will accept up to 127.5 amps of charge versus an AGM 
acceptance of 204 amps.  I have a 40-amp fixed AC charger and 60-amp 
alternators on my twin engines - meaning that I can't charge my flooded 
batteries as fast as they will accept a charge.  Having AGM batteries would 
be even more underkill as far as my charging system goes, so I wouldn't 
save any charging time.  
 
Price comparison:  8D flooded deep-cycle batteries at Fisheries Supply:  
$374.49.  8D AGM batteries at Fisheries Supply:  $814.36.  I can't 
justify more than 2x the price for the no-spill convenience.  Plus, flooded 
batteries will tolerate overcharging better than AGM or gel-cells will.
 
My advice is worth what you paid for it :^)
 
 

 
 

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"UnifliteWorld" group.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/unifliteworld/-/E9lNzAuq4-kJ.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/unifliteworld?hl=en.

Reply via email to