2009/10/21 François Chaplais <francois.chapl...@mines-paristech.fr> > just a remark about all the legal stuff in this thread: > > assume you have a non totally permissive license on your code, and that > somebody breaks the license, by, let us say, making a copy of the code and > commercially distributing it > > Now who will flex the muscle to prevent this? Who will pay the lawyer(s)? > > If there is nothing prepared at this stage, you may as well drop all of > this legal stuff...
Quick answer to that: 1. There are a number of organisations like the Free Software Foundation, that have and will continue to take on legal case which they fund, often with high profile pro-bono lawyers to defend such violations. This has been done before and they will continue to do so in order to help set legal precedents. 2. Some of the brightest lawyers in countries all around the world are part of the open source and Creative Commons networks. I've sat on the steering committee here in the UK for Creative Commons, and can vouch for how bright and surprisingly generous these people can be. Someone who rips one of these licenses off makes a LOT of people very angry, it is a foolish company or individual that messes with this network. Much easier to pick on someone else. 3. Being explicit about your licenses costs you nothing, help everyone be clear about what they can and cannot do, and in a direct answer to the skeptisism you rightly raise, makes a companies lawyer think twice, about breaking the terms laid out in the license. 4. You don't need to be convinced of any of the above. None of the philosophy, banter and arguments littered around the internet. You can simply learn from the practices of successful communities. There are plenty of examples of robust scaleable long lasting software communities that have adopted clear open source licenses. Looking around and trying to find successful code sharing communities without any licensing - and you'll come up short. Why? I think it is reasonable to conclude that being clear about your licensing helps. _______________________________________________ use-revolution mailing list use-revolution@lists.runrev.com Please visit this url to subscribe, unsubscribe and manage your subscription preferences: http://lists.runrev.com/mailman/listinfo/use-revolution