Beware of activating the anonymous role - I just did it (it seemed a reasonable thing to do at the time) and it made my public instance inaccessible. The anonymous role in the authoring instance seems to be set to deny anonymous access to any URLs. That makes sense once you think about it, but the problem is that these kinds of asymmetries between the authoring and public instances are not at all obvious to the user - there's nothing to tell me that it's a bad idea to publish that role. Almost every problem I've had with Magnolia has ended up coming down to these kinds of problems - the two instances getting out of sync or something from the authoring instance not being pushed to the public instance or being pushed when it shouldn't have.

Magnolia seems to be getting a lot more user friendly these days, but it still seems to me that the way that it exposes very brittle configuration in a very raw way is extremely dangerous - it's just too easy to do the wrong thing and break something without having the faintest idea why.

I've always thought that the Dialog mechanism would be ideal for making preference pages - surely it would be better if higher level configuration pages could be defined in a similar way to the way that we define paragraph editing dialogues?

just a thought,
josh

----------------------------------------------------------------
for list details see
http://documentation.magnolia.info/docs/en/editor/stayupdated.html
----------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to