Hello,

You said that "data is distributed very badly across slots"; do you mean that only a small number of subtasks is reading from HDFS, or that the keyed data is only processed by a few subtasks?


Flink does prioritize date locality over date distribution when reading the files, but the function after the groupBy() should still make full use of the parallelism of the cluster. Do note that data skew can affect how much data is distributed to each node, i.e. if 80% of your data has the same key (or rather hash), they will all end up on the same node.

On 12.03.2018 13:49, Reinier Kip wrote:

Relevant versions: Beam 2.1, Flink 1.3.

------------------------------------------------------------------------
*From:* Reinier Kip <r...@bol.com>
*Sent:* 12 March 2018 13:45:47
*To:* user@flink.apache.org
*Subject:* HDFS data locality and distribution

Hey all,


I'm trying to batch-process 30-ish files from HDFS, but I see that data is distributed very badly across slots. 4 out of 32 slots get 4/5ths of the data, another 3 slots get about 1/5th and a last slot just a few records. This probably triggers disk spillover on these slots and slows down the job immensely. The data has many many unique keys and processing could be done in a highly parallel manner. From what I understand, HDFS data locality governs which splits are assigned to which subtask.


  * I'm running a Beam on Flink on YARN pipeline.
  * I'm reading 30-ish files, whose records are later grouped by
    their millions of unique keys.
  * For now, I have 8 task managers by 4 slots. Beam sets all subtasks
    to have 32 parallelism.
  * Data seems to be localised to 9 out of the 32 slots, 3 out of the
    8 task managers.


Does the statement of input split assignment ring true? Is the fact that data isn't redistributed an effort from Flink to have high data locality, even if this means disk spillover for a few slots/tms and idleness for others? Is there any use for parallelism if work isn't distributed anyway?


Thanks for your time, Reinier


Reply via email to