On Dec 25, 2004, at 11:46 AM, L. Yeung wrote:

b. Are the tags made as class level sufficient
enough.
I honestly don't have much experience with web
deployment descriptors.

At the moment, I don't see how to usefully use xdoclet to construct a geronimo web plan, since all the information in the plan is at the web application level rather than the servlet level, which the class level tags would correspond to. Since none of the information is specific to a particular servlet, I don't think any information should be provided by a particular class. Am I missing something? Constructing the standard web.xml deployment descriptor could be useful, but this does not rely on anything having to do with geronimo.


(I dont know if I get this question right). I mean class level tags for geronimo-jetty.xml, such as security access, resource references and etc (???)

Those are the principal things that need to be resolved, but they apply across the entire web application rather than per servlet, so I question how appropriate it is to include the information needed to resolve them in a particular (servlet) source file. For ejbs, the jndi references are per ejb instance rather than per ejb application/module, but the security role-mapping still applies across the entire module.


IIRC xdoclet suffers from a similar problem even for the spec deployment descriptors, in that a particular class may appear many times in a descriptor with a different environment each time, whereas xdoclet only provides the means to include it once, with a single environment specified in the source file. I have no idea how to solve this problem or even if it has already been solved in xdoclet 2.

many thanks,
david jencks


Thanks.

-len


__________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com




Reply via email to