I have found that if the commons-logging.jar file is in my app's lib directory, then Geronimo chokes on it. However, deployments of the exact same WAR file on Tomcat, Sun, Oracle servers work fine if the commons-logging.jar file is present. I always figured it was a class loader error in Geronimo. Maybe that assumption is incorrect!!??
- Ray Clough -----Original Message----- From: Dain Sundstrom [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, April 13, 2006 9:53 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: commons logging issue Our long term goal is to isolate web applications from the system classes. This means that by default a web application will only see the spec jars required by the servlet spec. Then if an application needs more jars, they can either add them to the WEB-INF/lib or the geronimo repository and add a dependency. I would have liked to get this into 1.1, but I think 1.1 will ship before I can get to it. -dain On Apr 13, 2006, at 7:18 AM, Guilherme Rios wrote: > Thanks Pablo, > > Should this be addressed? The practical impact is sometimes an > application will deploy fine in Geronimo/Tomcat but not Geronimo/ > Jetty (because it will use jars unavailable in the former) or the > other way around (because app jars will conflict with Geronimo's, as > already discussed in other thread). > Is there any reason why the repositories differ for both versions? > > Cheers, > > Guilherme > > Pablo wrote: >> Guilherme Rios wrote: >>> Paul McMahan wrote: >>> >>>> >>>> I'm not sure why deployment didn't fail in jetty, perhaps you would >>>> have seen a failure later on when you tried to access your >>>> servlets(?). >>> >>> >>> Hi, >>> >>> I recall noticing a few days ago some jars missing from >>> Geronimo/Jetty /repository when compared to Geronimo/Tomcat. >>> Commons Logging was one, there was also one or two others missing. >>> Can anyone pls confirm that? (I do not have access to my >>> installation at this very moment) >>> This could be the reason why it works on Geronimo/Jetty but not >>> Geronimo/Tomcat. >>> >>> Regards, >>> >>> Guilherme >> Hi >> I'm sending lists of jars for both jetty and tomcat. There are a few >> differences... >> Cheers >> Pablo > Send instant messages to your online friends http:// > uk.messenger.yahoo.com
