Hi Eli, Unfortunately that interpretation of the data doesn't work. Avery's example input simply defines a graph that looks like a circular linked list. The shortest path from node 14 to node 0 is 1400, but the shortest path from node 5 to node 0 is not 1000- it will be the sum of all edge costs between node 5,6,7 etc all the way through 14 until the graph wraps around back to node 0. The resulting output looks exactly like the input. That can't be right.
Is there any way the documented example on the wiki could be updated to briefly describe how to interpret the result? I can't imagine I'm the only one having trouble understanding this... I am going to try experimenting with even simpler graphs to see if I cant figure out how this is all working. Thanks! Sent from phone -----Original Message----- From: Eli Reisman [[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>] Sent: Wednesday, October 10, 2012 05:34 PM Eastern Standard Time To: [email protected] Subject: Re: High-level questions about the ShortestPathsBenchmark example that ships with Giraph I think maybe the problem is the interpretation of the printout, which looks like it includes the out-edge ID's and values as well as the vertex value. I think the first two numbers in each outer bracket are the ID and VALUE (I and V generic types from application code) you want to read, the other stuff should be just as it was in the input as those are (I think) edge id's and values (E generic type from you Vertex application code) So the V (the 2nd value in the outer brackets for each printed line) should be the cost to get to your Source vertex from that vertex. If not, I need to look back at the IO Format and the example code, I'm just guessing based on memory. On Tue, Oct 9, 2012 at 5:32 AM, Magyar, Bence (US SSA) <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: Hi Eli, I’ve found the past email I think you are referring to. I found an email from Friday 27 July, 2012. In his email, Amir A. posed a similar question about how to interpret the output from the ShortestPath Example. Amir wrote: “Moreover, looking at the output file of shortestpath example provided on the website, it seems that it is exactly the same like input files combined together. Both the output file and the input files (put together) look a like. Is this correct and the expected result?” Unfortunately, I don’t see a response to his email in the archives. Can you please quickly explain how the ShortestPath output should be interpreted? Let’s just look at a quick snippet of the output: hduser ~/giraph-src/bin $ hadoop fs -cat shortestPathsOutput/part* [5,1000,[[6,500]]] [14,9100,[[0,1400]]] I know that this is: node 5 (with value 14) has an edge to node 6 with edge cost 500. And: node 14 (with value 9100) has an edge to node 0 with an edge cost of 1400. But if the ShortestPathExample computes the shortest path from node 0 to every other node, I am expecting to see output like: [0, 10500, [1, <edge-cost-to-1> ] [0, 10500, [2, <edge-cost-to-2> ] [0, 10500, [3, <edge-cost-to-3> ] Etc… Am I thinking about this the right way? Bence From: Eli Reisman [mailto:[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>] Sent: Monday, October 08, 2012 6:48 PM To: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]> Subject: Re: High-level questions about the ShortestPathsBenchmark example that ships with Giraph No you've got it right. There's another mail from a few months back on the mailing list that explains the output. I'm glad to see its working for you! Eli On Sun, Oct 7, 2012 at 7:50 PM, Magyar, Bence (US SSA) <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: Hi Eli, Well, I’ve followed your advice and have gotten the SimpleShortestPathsVertex example running using the GiraphRunner. I am using the following command to launch the job: ./giraph ../target/giraph.jar org.apache.giraph.examples.SimpleShortestPathsVertex -if org.apache.giraph.io.JsonLongDoubleFloatDoubleVertexInputFormat -ip /user/hduser/shortestPathsInputGraph -of org.apache.giraph.io.JsonLongDoubleFloatDoubleVertexOutputFormat -op /user/hduser/shortestPathsOutput -w 3 As my input graph, I am using Avery’s sample input files from: http://ece.northwestern.edu/~aching/shortestPathsInputGraph.tar.gz After the job completes, my output matches the output referenced @ https://github.com/aching/Giraph/wiki/Shortest-Paths-Example (See below) hduser ~/giraph-src/bin $ hadoop fs -cat shortestPathsOutput/part* [5,1000,[[6,500]]] [14,9100,[[0,1400]]] [8,2800,[[9,800]]] [2,100,[[3,200]]] [11,5500,[[12,1100]]] [7,2100,[[8,700]]] [1,0,[[2,100]]] [10,4500,[[11,1000]]] [13,7800,[[14,1300]]] [4,600,[[5,400]]] [6,1500,[[7,600]]] [0,10500,[[1,0]]] [9,3600,[[10,900]]] [12,6600,[[13,1200]]] [3,300,[[4,300]]] However, I don’t quite understand how to interpret this output. The SimpleShortestPathsVertex should find the shortest path from (by default) vertex “1” to every other node. How should the above output be interpreted? The ShortestPath example on the wiki also stops short of explaining this point. Am I using the wrong output format? Thanks! Bence ________________________________ From: Eli Reisman [mailto:[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>] Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 6:05 PM To: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]> Subject: Re: High-level questions about the ShortestPathsBenchmark example that ships with Giraph Sorry, the Giraph website is a bit out of date regarding the user-configurable application code. The benchmark applications are meant for just that, and are not written to process input or output data or results. The code you are looking for is in the examples/ dir. These are applications (*Vertex classes) in Giraph. Regarding code from the examples/ directory: you can run it at the command line using the "giraph" script in the bin/ dir. There are many command line options (including for IO formats from the io/ dir) and input/output paths in your HDFS for your data. Until better docs are up (soon, sorry!) your best bet is to read some of the example apps in the examples/ and io/ dirs and read GiraphRunner.java and bin/giraph script to get a feel for how user-configured command-line runs are performed. You might also then feel comfortable writing some of your own application code. Sorry about the confusion, we will be posting better documentation of application-style runs ASAP. On Mon, Sep 24, 2012 at 1:50 PM, Magyar, Bence (US SSA) <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: Hello Giraph User Community, ( I am re-posting this question – I think I tried posting this before I confirmed my registration. Please pardon if this message is a duplicate ) This is my first post to this mailing list – I’m interested in learning more about Giraph and to do that I checked out the latest source code from https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/giraph/trunk and built it with maven. I am now running the shortestPathBenchMark example that ships with Giraph and have a few “high-level” questions: For the sake of this discussion, I am running the example with the following arguments: hadoop jar giraph.jar org.apache.giraph.benchmark.ShortestPathsBenchmark -c 1 -e 3 -v -V 50000 -w 4 The example takes about 90 seconds to complete on my 4-node hadoop cluster and I don’t see any errors or issues. 1. In computing a Dijkstra shortest path, we are looking for the shortest path from one node to another. What does ShortestPathsBenchmark use as the “starting” node? The “ending” node? 2. What edge weights are being used? The arguments don’t allow me to specify them. 3. Does ShortestPathsBenchmark produce any output data inside HDFS upon completion of this example, or is the example purely meant to visually illustrate processing time on my cluster? 4. Can I feed ShortestPathsBenchmark my own graph? 5. In the example above, I have specified 3 edges per vertex. If I were to specify only 2 edges per vertex, am I not effectively dealing with a graph that most closely resembles a “linked list”? When I set –e=2, the processing time is still somewhat comparable to –e = 3. Shouldn’t the graph be much simpler? I have seen the ShortestPathExample @ https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/GIRAPH/Shortest+Paths+Example and I was planning on working through that example as well, but I thought I’d ask about the benchmarking example first. Thanks! Bence
