Thanks Nick Then why would this be considered an xRDP big. Does the RDP Protocol Spec indicate "0" should be valid ?
On Fri, Nov 5, 2021, 1:18 PM Nick Couchman <[email protected]> wrote: > On Fri, Nov 5, 2021 at 9:53 AM brian mullan <[email protected]> > wrote: > >> Mike/Adrian >> >> In a separate Thread Subject: *Difference between normal RDP and >> Guacamole’s RDP* >> <https://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/guacamole-user/202111.mbox/ajax/%3CCAOUMhd4%3DtUDFONM_e-MMyRRMhgYi6-QDHyhQtiFkeW47dwr9jg%40mail.gmail.com%3E> >> >> Adrian said:: >> >> *When you run Guacamole RDP. Traffic is:* >>> >>> *A) (RDP) Between Guacamole (freeRDP) and remote computer.* >>> >> >> I've used FreeRDP for quite a while and it's worked well for me in many >> ways. >> >> I recently had an issue where my newest Guacamole install was having >> problems. >> >> Two VMs lets call X and Y. >> >> - X is an Ubuntu 20.04 where Guacamole was installed. >> - Y is also Ubuntu 20.04 with xRDP installed and several options for >> Desktop Environment (MATE, Gnome, etc). >> >> So Guacamole was configured for a Connection to Y. >> >> Everything worked except "Drive Redirection". >> >> I would get a Folder on Y's Desktop and in that folder I'd see a GUACFS >> folder but there was never a "Download" folder >> no matter how many changes I tried. >> >> Note: In the past this always worked for me. >> >> Then I tried just using FreeRDP from a Terminal on X and everything >> worked OK including Drive Redirection! >> >> In a *separate email to the Guacamole User alias >> <https://lists.apache.org/thread/s99rf1zl1hrtfoqg6zkrvbl9ccb0zoj8> *about >> my problem Mike responded that there was an xRDP bug >> >> *Yes - this is a bug in XRDP related to RDPDR device IDs. Newer versions >>> of XRDP should work correctly. See:* >>> >>> *- Mike* >> >> >> In Case.... >> >> >> *If Both approaches are using FreeRDP * >> >> *and * >> *In Both approaches the connection is via the same xRDP on Y * >> >> I guess I don't understand Mike's statement above... >> >> *Does Guacamole send a different "RDPDR device ID" than the command line >> FreeRDP Sends?* >> > > Yes, that's my understanding based on the various posts - that Guacamole > sends ID 0, whereas other clients (FreeRDP, Microsoft, etc.) send something > other than 0 - maybe they start at 1? > > -Nick >
