Hi Paul, Sorry I didn't see your last email.
Do you mind to create a Jira with your features repo ? I will check your features XML and try to reproduce. Regards JB On Fri, Jul 12, 2024 at 5:59 PM Paul Spencer <[email protected]> wrote: > > I have done some more testing and realized the install attribute allowable > values are "auto" and "manual". > > The following behavior does not meet my expectations > - Behavior of install-mixed-1.0.0.xml does not match documentation in section > "4.10.13 - Provisioning Deployer", > https://karaf.apache.org/manual/latest/#_deployer. Specifically the > documentation > states the only features with install="auto" will be installed. In the > case of install-mixed-1.0.0, the auto feature was not installed. > > - None of the features in install-manual-1.0.0.xml appear in feature:list > > - The configuration element for all features with install="auto" or no > install attribute created entries even though the feature is listed as > uninstalled. > > This replay is to primarily to document the results of my testing, which was > prompted by my attempt to build a features.xml to install the server or > client implementation. > > *** > * tail:log output > *** > 10:50:13.609 INFO > [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy] Installing > bundle install-manual / 1.0.0 > 10:50:13.615 INFO > [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy] Installing > bundle install-none / 1.0.0 > 10:50:13.619 INFO > [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy] Installing > bundle install-auto / 1.0.0 > 10:50:13.624 INFO > [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy] Installing > bundle install-mixed / 1.0.0 > 10:50:13.651 INFO > [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy] Started bundle: > feature:file:/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy/install-mixed-1.0.0.xml > 10:50:13.657 INFO > [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy] Started bundle: > feature:file:/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy/install-none-1.0.0.xml > 10:50:13.660 INFO > [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy] Started bundle: > feature:file:/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/deploy/install-auto-1.0.0.xml > 10:50:13.692 INFO [activator-1-thread-1] Registering commands for bundle > org.apache.karaf.shell.ssh/4.4.6 > 10:50:13.704 INFO [activator-1-thread-1] No detected/configured > IoServiceFactoryFactory; using Nio2ServiceFactoryFactory > 10:50:13.835 INFO [features-3-thread-1] No deployment change. > 10:50:13.843 INFO [features-3-thread-1] Done. > 10:50:13.947 INFO [features-3-thread-1] No deployment change. > 10:50:13.953 INFO [features-3-thread-1] Done. > 10:50:14.058 INFO [features-3-thread-1] No deployment change. > 10:50:14.064 INFO [features-3-thread-1] Done. > 10:50:22.650 INFO [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc] > Updating configuration {case~install-none} from > /Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc/case-install-none.cfg > 10:50:22.652 INFO [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc] > Updating configuration {case~install-mixed} from > /Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc/case-install-mixed.cfg > 10:50:22.654 INFO [fileinstall-/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc] > Updating configuration {case~install-auto} from > /Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc/case-install-auto.cfg > 10:51:21.253 INFO [CM Configuration Updater (Update: > pid=org.ops4j.pax.logging)] Sending Event Admin notification (configuration > successful) to org/ops4j/pax/logging/Configuration > ^C~ > > > karaf@root()> > feature:list | grep case | sort > case-install-auto-bar │ 1.0.0 │ x │ Started > │ install-auto-1.0.0 │ > case-install-auto-foo │ 1.0.0 │ x │ Started > │ install-auto-1.0.0 │ > case-install-mixed-auto │ 1.0.0 │ │ Uninstalled > │ install-mixed-1.0.0 │ > case-install-mixed-manual │ 1.0.0 │ │ Uninstalled > │ install-mixed-1.0.0 │ > case-install-mixed-none │ 1.0.0 │ │ Uninstalled > │ install-mixed-1.0.0 │ > case-install-none-bar │ 1.0.0 │ │ Uninstalled > │ install-none-1.0.0 │ > case-install-none-foo │ 1.0.0 │ │ Uninstalled > │ install-none-1.0.0 │ > karaf@root()> list > START LEVEL 100 , List Threshold: 50 > ID │ State │ Lvl │ Version │ Name > ───┼────────┼─────┼─────────┼───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── > 33 │ Active │ 80 │ 4.4.6 │ Apache Karaf :: OSGi Services :: Event > 53 │ Active │ 80 │ 1.0.0 │ install-manual > 54 │ Active │ 80 │ 1.0.0 │ install-none > 55 │ Active │ 80 │ 1.0.0 │ install-auto > 56 │ Active │ 80 │ 1.0.0 │ install-mixed > karaf@root()> > > *** > * install-auto-1.0.0.xml > *** > <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?> > <features xmlns="http://karaf.apache.org/xmlns/features/v1.6.0"; > name="install-auto-1.0.0"> > <feature name="case-install-auto-foo" version="1.0.0" install="auto"> > <config name="case-install-auto" append="true"> > fooAutoInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > <feature name="case-install-auto-bar" version="1.0.0" install="auto"> > <config name="case-install-auto" append="true"> > barAutoInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > </features> > > *** > * install-manual-1.0.0.xml > *** > <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?> > <features xmlns="http://karaf.apache.org/xmlns/features/v1.6.0"; > name="install-manual-1.0.0"> > <feature name="case-install-manual-foo" version="1.0.0" install="manual"> > <config name="case-install-manual" append="true"> > fooManualInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > <feature name="case-install-manual-bar" version="1.0.0" install="manual"> > <config name="case-install-manual" append="true"> > barManualInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > </features> > > *** > * install-mixed-1.0.0.xml > *** > <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?> > <features xmlns="http://karaf.apache.org/xmlns/features/v1.6.0"; > name="install-mixed-1.0.0"> > <feature name="case-install-mixed-auto" version="1.0.0" install="auto"> > <config name="case-install-mixed" append="true"> > fooAutoInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > <feature name="case-install-mixed-manual" version="1.0.0" install="manual"> > <config name="case-install-mixed" append="true"> > barManualInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > <feature name="case-install-mixed-none" version="1.0.0"> > <config name="case-install-mixed" append="true"> > foobarNoneInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > </features> > > *** > * install-none-1.0.0.xml > *** > <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?> > <features xmlns="http://karaf.apache.org/xmlns/features/v1.6.0"; > name="install-none-1.0.0"> > <feature name="case-install-none-foo" version="1.0.0"> > <config name="case-install-none" append="true"> > fooNoneInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > <feature name="case-install-none-bar" version="1.0.0"> > <config name="case-install-none" append="true"> > barNoneInstalled = 1.0.0 > </config> > </feature> > </features> > > *** > * case-install-auto.cfg > *** > barAutoInstalled = 1.0.0 > org.apache.karaf.features.configKey = case-install-auto > felix.fileinstall.filename = > file:/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc/case-install-auto.cfg > fooAutoInstalled = 1.0.0 > > > *** > * case-install-mixed.cfg > *** > fooAutoInstalled = 1.0.0 > org.apache.karaf.features.configKey = case-install-mixed > felix.fileinstall.filename = > file:/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc/case-install-mixed.cfg > foobarNoneInstalled = 1.0.0 > > > *** > * case-install-none.cfg > *** > barNoneInstalled = 1.0.0 > org.apache.karaf.features.configKey = case-install-none > felix.fileinstall.filename = > file:/Users/paul/Documents/apache-karaf-4.4.6/etc/case-install-none.cfg > fooNoneInstalled = 1.0.0 > > > > On Jul 11, 2024, at 2:31 PM, Paul Spencer <[email protected]> > > wrote: > > > > Karaf 4.4.3 and Karaf 4.4.6 > > > > Placing a feature.xml file in the deploy directory will not add features to > > Karaf if all features contain the attribute 'install', i.e. <feature > > name="..." install="...">. As long as one feature does not contain the > > attribute "install", all features in the the file will be listed in > > "feature:list" > > > > karaf@root()> feature:list | grep case > > case-install-true-foo │ 1.0.0 │ x │ Started > > │ install-true-1.0.0 │ > > case-install-true-bar │ 1.0.0 │ │ > > Uninstalled │ install-true-1.0.0 │ > > karaf@root()> > > > > *** > > * deploy/install-false-1.0.0.xml > > *** > > <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?> > > <features xmlns="http://karaf.apache.org/xmlns/features/v1.6.0"; > > name="install-false-1.0.0"> > > <feature name="case-install-false-foo" install="false" version="1.0.0"> > > <bundle > > start="false">mvn:org.apache.commons/commons-lang3/3.14.0</bundle> > > </feature> > > <feature name="case-install-false-bar" install="false" version="1.0.0"> > > <bundle > > start="false">mvn:commons-beanutils/commons-beanutils/1.9.4</bundle> > > </feature> > > </features> > > > > *** > > * deploy/install-true-1.0.0.xml > > *** > > <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?> > > <features xmlns="http://karaf.apache.org/xmlns/features/v1.6.0"; > > name="install-true-1.0.0"> > > <feature name="case-install-true-foo" version="1.0.0"> > > <bundle > > start="false">mvn:org.apache.commons/commons-lang3/3.14.0</bundle> > > </feature> > > <feature name="case-install-true-bar" install="false" version="1.0.0"> > > <bundle > > start="false">mvn:commons-beanutils/commons-beanutils/1.9.4</bundle> > > </feature> > > </features> > > > > > > Is this a bug? > > > > Paul Spencer > >
