No, the issue was discussed but never reached critical mass. I typically do a binary search to find the best value setting T1==T2 and then tweak T1 up a bit. For feeding k-means, this latter step is not so important.

If you could figure out a way to automate this we would be interested. Conceptually, using the RandomSeedGenerator to sample a few vectors and comparing them with your chosen DistanceMeasure would give you a hint at the T-value to begin the search. A utility to do that would be a useful contribution.

On 5/9/12 8:36 PM, Pat Ferrel wrote:
Some thoughts on https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MAHOUT-563

Did anything ever get done with this? Ted mentions limited usefulness. This may be true but the cases he mentions as counter examples are also not very good for using canopy ahead of kmeans, no? That info would be a useful result. To use canopies I find myself running it over and over trying to see some inflection in the number of clusters. Why not automate this? Even if the data shows nothing, that is itself an answer of value and it would save a lot of hand work to find out the same thing.



Reply via email to