Well, after installing Midgard Lite on two Linux based isp hosts and a
Windows 2k system, I've approached near zero productivity with the
toolset after a week of work.

There are tempting hints that it might be an interesting system to
run, but 0.8.2 is just too unstable at this point. The mailing list
archives are a good resource. Some issues dealing with PHP, MySQL, and
Apache dependencies were there in the archive, though it took way too
much effort of searching in the Yahoo system to find them; I
eventually used Google's better search ability to locate appropriate
posts faster. An install FAQ which compiles some of these issues would
be nice. 

I tried a Win2k install on my laptop, just because I already had LAMP
mostly installed already. The only thing that works in my Windows 2k
install is the sample site pages. That is, it can pull bootstrapped
articles from the database and present them, but that's about it.
Aegir CMS loops in a vicious circle from the login page -> newframeset
-> login page. The Asgard page opens, but the 'Create new' links all
pop me back to the index.php page. Old Midgard Admin appears to be
missing images and fails with an error about RCSLib.class (line 74),
presumably due to the non-existance of /var/cvs directory under Win2k.
SpiderAdmin almost appears to work, but fails for the same reason, an
RCSLib error. Looks like the admin interfaces depend pretty strongly
on RCS/CVS command line utilities and fixed directories, some of which
may be present under Linux but which don't exist under Windows. 

Usability wise, I can't comment too much because not much works on any
of the installs. I wish I could see Aegir in action under Lite. The
other admin pages expose quite a lot of raw PHP code, and IMHO don't
suite what my customer will need for providing easily navigable
administration for a site. I'm wondering if Aegir is really much
different, in terms of raw PHP exposure or organization. 

I may revisit the full Midgard project again, and would like to hear
any feedback regarding the issues I mentioned. But for now Midgard
Lite is not working out very well for me.

Cheers!


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to