Hi Jacques:

Thanks for pointing this out. Initially I thought that no one really cared. Next update to the site I will add such a disclaimer.

Regards,
Ruth
On 4/17/12 7:32 AM, Jacques Le Roux wrote:
Thanks Ruth,

I think it's pretty clear, even if a small sentence about it on the main page would not hurt ;o)
Anyway, if you got ASF consent I have nothing more to say

Jacques

From: "Ruth Hoffman" <[email protected]>
Hi Jacques & List:

I've had this discussion with the Apache Foundation in the past as I too am concerned about copyright infringement and misrepresenting my purpose. The Foundation's legal advisers found my "interpretation" of the rules satisfactory.

FYI, I do clearly state the relationship with the Apache Foundation here:

http://www.myofbiz.com/control/faqs

More specifically, I clearly write:

   Is MyOFBiz.com affiliated with the Apache Foundation or Apache OFBiz?

   No.


Best Regards,
Ruth

On 4/17/12 5:19 AM, Jacques Le Roux wrote:
Hi Daniel (and any person in the same situation),

I have noticed "your" site at http://www.ofbiz.cl

Like did for instance Marco Risaliti some time ago with http://www.ofbiz.it you need to clearly state that your site is not and official Apache OFBiz site.

The same applies to ofbiz.nl and ofbiz.th (maybe it's done but I did not find it clear like did Marco) and I guess others...

This is the minimum required, and actually you should not even use ofbiz in your domain names...
http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/#domains

see also there "Using the Apache Foo or similar graphic logos:"

Thanks

Jacques
PS : I think it's ok for http://www.myofbiz.com because it does not '"mimic" official OFBiz site and does not use ofbiz in its domain name. Though a little note about not being an official Apache OFBiz site would not hurt...
The same apllies for
http://www.ofbiz.biz/
http://www.ofbiz.de/
etc. (you know better than us... for now...)
This my own interpretation of the ASF rules and I don't act on behalf of APache OFBiz PMC, but I think I'm right to ask



Reply via email to