On 16-Apr-2010, at 04:41, Nick Burch wrote:

> On Thu, 15 Apr 2010, Andre-John Mas wrote:
>> What I don't seem to understand is why the Excel 2003 parser (HSSF) is being 
>> used when I call WorkbookFactory.create() on this file, instead of the Excel 
>> 2007 parser (XSSF). The file ends in '.xlsx'.
> 
> Since you got the output that you did from POIFSLister, it's clear that your 
> document in an OLE2 document, not an ooxml one. That's also why you get the 
> exception you do when you try to load it with XSSF.

The odd thing is that if I try resaving it as a new Office 2007 file or a new 
Office 2003 the file, with Excel 2007, it still can't be read by POI, even if 
it they can be reopend with Excel. Its almost as if it is a data issue.

Additional investigation: I tried opening the file with "Numbers" on the Mac 
and it couldn't open it. Trying to open it with Office 2008, on MacOS X, and I 
get the message "The workbook contains content that is not supported  by Excel  
2008 for Mac: OLE DB query tables". Trying to unzip the, or look at it in a hex 
editor indicates this is not zipped content.

I am really going to have to investigate how this file was created in the first 
place, and why Excel is saving an apparent Office 2007 is saving the document 
as OLE. Is it possible that Excel will use the OLE format if there is a feature 
not supported by the OOXML format?

If any of the developers want to look at the file, I will happily supply it.

André-John


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to