I suspect this restriction is there to support the validator. XHTML mandates the use of 'id' in place of 'name' in various situations.

That said, you can still predict what the 'id' value will be; in this case, it will take the name of the FormBean associated with the form. So your AJAX calls could just use that name to reference the form.

L.

Michael Rush wrote:
I was just looking into upgrading my app from 1.2.9 to 1.3.4 and have run into a snag:

2006-08-01 15:33:49,911 (ERROR) InsertTag.doEndTag - ServletException in '/pages/site/entry.jsp': Cannot specify "styleId" when in XHTML mode as the HTML "id" attribute is already used to store the bean name javax.servlet.ServletException: Cannot specify "styleId" when in XHTML mode as the HTML "id" attribute is already used to store the bean name

FormTag dictates that the styleId attribute cannot be set in the html:form tag when using xhtml mode:

   protected void renderName(StringBuffer results)
            throws JspException {
        if (this.isXhtml()) {
            if (getStyleId() == null) {
                renderAttribute(results, "id", beanName);
            } else {
throw new JspException(messages.getMessage("formTag.ignoredId"));
            }
        } else {
            renderAttribute(results, "name", beanName);
            renderAttribute(results, "id", getStyleId());
        }
    }

The question is, why?

Couldn't it just as easily be done as the following?

        if (this.isXhtml()) {
            if (getStyleId() == null) {
                renderAttribute(results, "id", beanName);
            } else {
                renderAttribute(results, "id", getStyleId());
            }
        }

We're using quite a bit of AJAX in our application and referring to document elements by id quite regularly, not to mention that stylesheets reference specific ids as well (i.e. all of our forms have a styleId attribute). Going through and renaming all of the ids of the forms doesn't seem very attractive. Can someone verify that it's necessary?

Thanks,
Michael


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to