1. I've used modular projects so far (struts and Spring MVC). I think that using modular projects is the way to go. Normally you will have business logic that you perhaps want to expose through other channels than web or reuse, so it's better to separate it in an own module.
2. I think in some cases that I would use the full source archetype. In some contexts it could be useful to start with full sourcecode and modify it instead of tweaking the bundled logic in a way that makes you happy. An example would of course be the core model classes, which sometimes make sense to modify. And yes, upgrading would in that case not be an issue. 3. In other projects we have used JMeter, and have been happy with that. I've read some Selenium documentation, but haven't been convinsed to change so far. mraible wrote: > > A couple of questions for folks using (or planning to use) 2.x: > > 1. As far as archetypes go, are you using basic or modular? > > 2. If there was a 3rd type of archetype that included the full source > (like AppFuse 1.x), would you use it over the existing basic or > modular archetypes? If yes, I'm assuming upgrading is not that big of > an issue for you? > > 3. Do you use the Canoo WebTests? If not, how do you do UI testing? > If so, would you prefer Selenium? > > <rambling> > On my current project, I integrated Selenium to replace Canoo and got > tests working in both IE and Firefox (I even found a bug that only > happens in IE). The HTML-based tests are great for running in Selenium > IDE and using the <selenese> Ant task, but they don't allow i18n or > dynamic values AFAICT. I've gotten the Java-based tests working as > well. I think it's good to support both, but it probably makes sense > to use the Java-based tests in AppFuse core if we're going to > replicate the current functionality where we can test all locales. Of > course, we could probably parse/replace keys in the HTML files, but > that sounds XDoclet-ish where it works from Maven, but not very well > from the IDE. > </rambling> > > Thanks, > > Matt > > -- > http://raibledesigns.com > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/Questions-for-2.x%3A-Archetypes-and-UI-Testing-tf3364157s2369.html#a9361140 Sent from the AppFuse - User mailing list archive at Nabble.com. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
