(Sorry for the late reply everyone...been busy with non-kannel related commitments...)
"my_kannel" is an HTTP SMSC module derived from the "kannel" HTTP SMSC. Look at: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg04106.html CosmoStation's situation (and BTW, it would be really nice to have real names instead of nicknames in the "full name" section of a To: line...) most likely is due to 3 factors: 1) More than one SMSC routing path for an SMS. 2) An allowed-smsc-id declaration restricting access to the SMSC. 3) The different ways the smsbox handles MT SMS as a reply to an MO SMS (an exec/file/text opposed to get-url/post-url/post-xml).. What is happening is that the smsbox generates an MT reply SMS for the sms-services defined as exec, file, and text. But, smsbox does not add the smsc-id to the SMS Msg structure used internally by Kannel to represent an SMS. This behavior differs from the get-url, post-url, post-xml in that all three of the above will include the smsc-id in the SMS Msg structure that will be passed to the bearerbox. Because you have an allowed-smsc-id declaration for each of your SMSCs, the bearerbox could not find a suitable SMSC delivery agent for the MT reply SMS generated from "text"-based sms-services. Since the smsc-id in the SMS Msg structure was NULL for the "text"-based sms-services, it did not match any of the smsc-ids listed in any of your allowed-smsc-id declarations for the SMSCs. That is why you go the "Cannot find SMSCConn for message to ..." warning and subsequent "No SMSCes to receive message..." warning in your bearerbox logs. But, the sms-service that used a get-url did include an smsc-id into the SMS Msg structure. As a result, it successfully passed the evaluation in the gateway/gw/smscconn.c:smscconn_usable() function and the message was delivered. Is this a bug? Only if you have the same three factors again. If the bearerbox only had one SMSC connection, then this would not be a problem since: 1) You would not need smsc-ids. 2) You would not assign an ACL via an allowed-smsc-id declaration. I'll post a enquire over on the [email protected] group about this issue. For a quick solution without changing the code and still allowing for the use of allowed-smsc-id for access restrictions: - only use get-url, post-url, or post-xml for all your sms-services. If you want to fix the code, then look on the [email protected] mailing list or the Mantis bugtracking system (http://bugs.kannel.org) on Friday for the patch. See ya... d.c. **>From: "Rodrigo A. Cremaschi" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> **>To: "CosmoStation" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, <[email protected]> **>Subject: Re: problem with multiple SMSC **>Date: Thu, 24 Feb 2005 09:52:13 -0300 **> **>Hi there, **> **>Why are you setting "system-type = my_kannel" ? **> **>"system-type" should be 'kannel', 'brunet', 'xidris' or 'wapme'. **>----- Original Message ----- **>From: "CosmoStation" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> **>To: <[email protected]> **>Sent: Thursday, February 24, 2005 8:07 AM **>Subject: problem with multiple SMSC **> **> **>> When I use only one SMSC everything is ok. **>> When I use multiple SMSCs there is a serious problem. It seems that **>> only one service is routed properly and the others (including the **>> default/catchall) are not routed to provide MT smses. **>> The sms-service with keyword "HOR" functions properly, but the other do **>not. **>> **>> **>> I tried allow-smsc-id and deny-smsc-id variables in the "group = smsc" **>> but neither worked as I was exepted. **>> **>> Here is an abstract from the access.log file: **>> **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 Log begins **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:21 Receive SMS [SMSC:car2] [SVC:] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:306944111111] [to:4541] [flags:0:0:0:-1:-1] [msg:7:hor rak] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:21 Sent SMS [SMSC:car2] [SVC:hor] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:4541] [to:306944111111] [flags:-1:0:-1:-1:-1] [msg:160:Imatemnogo shansove da izpyknete i da lansirate ideite si. Shte imatevyzmozhnostta da obshtuvate s obichani ot vas hora. Intuicijata vishte vi pomogne da nam] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:21 Sent SMS [SMSC:car2] [SVC:hor] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:4541] [to:306944111111] [flags:-1:0:-1:-1:-1] [msg:77:eritereshenija na problemite, koito vi pritesnjavat. AEGEAN MEDIA HOROSCOPES] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:31 Receive SMS [SMSC:car1] [SVC:] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:306977666666] [to:3300] [flags:0:0:0:-1:-1] [msg:8:hor deva] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:31 Sent SMS [SMSC:car1] [SVC:hor] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:3300] [to:306977666666] [flags:-1:0:-1:-1:-1] [msg:160:Obstojatelstvata, koito se syzdavat v zhivota vi, vi pomagat da si izjasnite dosta neshta. Vecherta posvetete na zabavlenija v kompanijata na prijatelite si, no] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:31 Sent SMS [SMSC:car1] [SVC:hor] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:3300] [to:306977666666] [flags:-1:0:-1:-1:-1] [msg:67: bydete sdyrzhani vyv finansovo otnoshenie. AEGEAN MEDIA HOROSCOPES] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:48 Receive SMS [SMSC:car1] [SVC:] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:306977666666] [to:3300] [flags:0:0:0:-1:-1] [msg:4:lala] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:56:14 Receive SMS [SMSC:car2] [SVC:] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:306944111111] [to:4541] [flags:0:0:0:-1:-1] [msg:4:koko] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 Receive SMS [SMSC:car2] [SVC:] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:306944111111] [to:4541] [flags:0:0:0:-1:-1] [msg:4:help] [udh:0:] **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 Receive SMS [SMSC:car1] [SVC:] [ACT:] [BINF:] [from:306977666666] [to:3300] [flags:0:0:0:-1:-1] [msg:4:help] [udh:0:] **>> **>> **>> **>> Here is my config file: **>> **>> # **>> group = core **>> admin-port = 18000 **>> smsbox-port = 18001 **>> admin-password = foo **>> admin-deny-ip = "*.*.*.*" **>> admin-allow-ip = "127.0.0.1;10.35.2.102" **>> log-file = "/tmp/kannel/kannel.log" **>> box-deny-ip = "*.*.*.*" **>> box-allow-ip = "127.0.0.1;10.35.2.102" **>> access-log = "/tmp/kannel/access.log" **>> store-file = "/tmp/kannel/kannel.store" **>> **>> group = smsc **>> smsc = http **>> smsc-id = car1 **>> system-type = my_kannel **>> port = 15555 **>> smsc-username = "ignored" **>> smsc-password = "ignored" **>> no-sender = false **>> no-coding = false **>> send-url = "http://10.35.2.102/astro/send2.php"; **>> connect-allow-ip = "127.0.0.1;10.35.2.102" **>> allowed-smsc-id = "car1" **>> **>> group = smsc **>> smsc = http **>> smsc-id = car2 **>> system-type = my_kannel **>> port = 14444 **>> smsc-username = "ignored" **>> smsc-password = "ignored" **>> no-sender = false **>> no-coding = false **>> send-url = "http://10.35.2.102/smsc2/send.php"; **>> connect-allow-ip = "127.0.0.1;10.35.2.102" **>> allowed-smsc-id = "car2" **>> **>> group = smsbox **>> bearerbox-host = 10.35.2.102 **>> sendsms-port = 19013 **>> log-file = "/tmp/kannel/smsbox.log" **>> log-level = 0 **>> access-log = "/tmp/kannel/Aaccess.log" **>> reply-couldnotfetch = "Could not Fetch" **>> reply-requestfailed = "Request Failed" **>> reply-emptymessage = "Empty message" **>> **>> group = sendsms-user **>> username = koko **>> password = lala **>> user-deny-ip = "*.*.*.*" **>> user-allow-ip = "10.35.2.102" **>> **>> group = sms-service **>> keyword = default **>> text = "Not a valid service. Send HELP to %P" **>> **>> group = sms-service **>> keyword = HELP **>> text = "Valid Commands: HOR, HELP" **>> **>> group = sms-service **>> keyword = HOR **>> max-messages = 2 **>> get-url = "http://10.35.2.102/smsc/prognoza.php?zod=%s"; **>> **>> **>> Here is what I see when run bearerbox (-v 1): **>> **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: Debug_lvl = 1, log_file = <none>, log_lvl = 0 **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] WARNING: DLR: using default 'internal' for storage type. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: DLR using storage type: internal **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: Added logfile `/tmp/kannel/kannel.log' with level `0'. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: Started access logfile `/tmp/kannel/access.log'. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: HTTP: Opening server at port 18000. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: BOXC: 'smsbox-max-pending' not set, using default (100). **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: DLR rerouting for smsc id <car1> disabled. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: HTTP: Opening server at port 15555. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: HTTP[car1]: Initiated and ready **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: DLR rerouting for smsc id <car2> disabled. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: HTTP: Opening server at port 14444. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: HTTP[car2]: Initiated and ready **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: ---------------------------------------- **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: Kannel bearerbox II version 1.4.0 starting **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: Loading store file `/tmp/kannel/kannel.store' **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: Store-file size 0, starting to unpack **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: Retrieved 0 messages, non-acknowledged messages: 0 **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:10 [19998] [0] INFO: MAIN: Start-up done, entering mainloop **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [19998] [12] INFO: Client connected from <10.35.2.102> **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:48 [19998] [12] WARNING: Cannot find SMSCConn for message to <306977666666>, rejected. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:48 [19998] [12] WARNING: Message rejected by bearerbox, no router! **>> 2005-02-24 12:56:14 [19998] [12] WARNING: Cannot find SMSCConn for message to <306944111111>, rejected. **>> 2005-02-24 12:56:14 [19998] [12] WARNING: Message rejected by bearerbox, no router! **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [12] WARNING: Cannot find SMSCConn for message to <306944111111>, rejected. **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [12] WARNING: Message rejected by bearerbox, no router! **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [12] WARNING: Cannot find SMSCConn for message to <306977666666>, rejected. **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [12] WARNING: Message rejected by bearerbox, no router! **>> **>> Here is the output of the smsbox (-v 1) **>> **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [20010] [0] INFO: Debug_lvl = 1, log_file = <none>, log_lvl = 0 **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [20010] [0] INFO: Starting to log to file /tmp/kannel/smsbox.log level 0 **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [20010] [0] INFO: Added logfile `/tmp/kannel/smsbox.log' with level `0'. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [20010] [0] INFO: Logging accesses to '/tmp/kannel/Aaccess.log'. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [20010] [0] INFO: Started access logfile `/tmp/kannel/Aaccess.log'. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [20010] [0] INFO: HTTP: Opening server at port 19013. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [20010] [0] INFO: Set up send sms service at port 19013 **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:12 [20010] [0] INFO: Connected to bearerbox at 10.35.2.102 port 18001. **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:21 [20010] [4] INFO: Starting to service <hor rak> from <306944111111> to <4541> **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:31 [20010] [4] INFO: Starting to service <hor deva> from <306977666666> to <3300> **>> 2005-02-24 12:55:48 [20010] [4] INFO: Starting to service <lala> from <306977666666> to <3300> **>> 2005-02-24 12:56:14 [20010] [4] INFO: Starting to service <koko> from <306944111111> to <4541> **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [20010] [4] INFO: Starting to service <help> from <306944111111> to <4541> **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [20010] [4] INFO: Starting to service <help> from <306977666666> to <3300> **>> **>> And this is an abstract from the kannel.log: **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [9] DEBUG: HTTP[car2]: Got request `/koko' **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [9] DEBUG: MY_HTTP[car2]: Received an HTTP request **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [9] DEBUG: HTTP[car2]: Constructing new SMS **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [9] DEBUG: HTTP[car2]: Sending reply **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [9] DEBUG: HTTP: Resetting HTTPClient for `10.35.2.102'. **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [9] DEBUG: HTTP[car2]: Destroying client information **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [13] DEBUG: send_msg: sending msg to box: <10.35.2.102> **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [13] DEBUG: boxc_sender: sent message to <10.35.2.102> **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [12] DEBUG: boxc_receiver: sms received **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [12] WARNING: Cannot find SMSCConn for message to <306944111111>, rejected. **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [12] WARNING: Message rejected by bearerbox, no router! **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [12] DEBUG: send_msg: sending msg to box: <10.35.2.102> **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [12] DEBUG: boxc_receiver: got ack **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:04 [19998] [1] DEBUG: Dumping 1 messages and 1 acks to store **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [7] DEBUG: HTTP[car1]: Got request `/moo' **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [7] DEBUG: MY_HTTP[car1]: Received an HTTP request **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [7] DEBUG: HTTP[car1]: Constructing new SMS **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [7] DEBUG: HTTP[car1]: Sending reply **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [7] DEBUG: HTTP: Resetting HTTPClient for `127.0.0.1'. **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [7] DEBUG: HTTP[car1]: Destroying client information **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [13] DEBUG: send_msg: sending msg to box: <10.35.2.102> **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [13] DEBUG: boxc_sender: sent message to <10.35.2.102> **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [12] DEBUG: boxc_receiver: sms received **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [12] WARNING: Cannot find SMSCConn for message to <306977666666>, rejected. **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [12] WARNING: Message rejected by bearerbox, no router! **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [12] DEBUG: send_msg: sending msg to box: <10.35.2.102> **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:11 [19998] [12] DEBUG: boxc_receiver: got ack **>> 2005-02-24 12:57:12 [19998] [12] DEBUG: boxc_receiver: heartbeat with load value 0 received **>> 2005-02-24 13:02:06 [19998] [2] DEBUG: HTTP: Destroying HTTPClient area 0x8bd1738. **>> 2005-02-24 13:02:06 [19998] [2] DEBUG: HTTP: Destroying HTTPClient for `10.35.2.102'. **>> 2005-02-24 13:02:21 [19998] [2] DEBUG: HTTP: Destroying HTTPClient area 0x8bd1768. **>> 2005-02-24 13:02:21 [19998] [2] DEBUG: HTTP: Destroying HTTPClient for `127.0.0.1'. **> **>
