Nigel, Thanks. See below ...
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- > Hash: SHA1 > > Updated. > > As I learn or some one tells me more, I'll keep refining the graph. > > Should I break AvSv into AMF,CLM & AMSv ? Instead of breaking it up, it would be good to mention what is AvSv by showing AvSv = SAF AMF + SAF CLM + AvM. (in braces). Also it might be nice to mention that GLSv is SAF LCK, MQSv is SAF MSG, EDSv is SAF EVT & CPSV is SAF CKPT. Some more corrections to the graph. 1. MDS & MDSv is one and the same. They shouldn't be separate and every service depends on MDSv/MDS. 2. There should be an arrow from AvSv to EDSv. 3. There should be an arrow from HISv to EDSv. 4. HPI & TIPC should have a different color to show that they aren't OpenSAF services per se and a legend showing what the colors mean. 5. There should be an arrow from MASv to PSSv (this is my mistake to not have included in the data sheet of dependencies) Thanks Sayan > - -Nigel > > > Saha Sayandeb-G19428 wrote: > | Nigel, > | > | Thanks for producing the graph. I can read it. I think > you're missing > | one arrow from AvSv to SRMSv. Once you get all the dependencies we > | could probably layer it better with straighter arrows and > put it up on > | Devel website. > | > | Sayan > | > |> -----Original Message----- > |> From: Nigel Croxon [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > |> Sent: Thursday, February 21, 2008 10:12 AM > |> To: Sekhar Reddy Ravi-G20226 > |> Cc: Saha Sayandeb-G19428; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; > |> users@list.opensaf.org > |> Subject: Re: [Users] Dependency data for OpenSAF Services > |> > | and now to that graph... > | > | > | (let me know if you can't read it) > | > | -Nigel > | > | > | > | Sekhar Reddy Ravi-G20226 wrote: > | | Sayan, > | | > | | Some corrections regarding dependency of GLSv > | | > | | 1) GLSv does not depend on CPSv for check pointing it uses flat > | | shared memory directly(Earlier GLSv used to use CPSv, but > | | later on we removed the dependency on CPSv) > | | 2) GLSv also depends on MASv > | | > | | The correct dependency is as follows GLSv or the SAF Lock Service > | | depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv > | | - MBCSv (for director redundancy) > | | - MASv > | | > | | Thanks, > | | Ravi > | | > | | -----Original Message----- > | | From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > | | [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Saha > | | Sayandeb-G19428 > | | Sent: Thursday, February 21, 2008 12:44 AM > | | To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; users@list.opensaf.org > | | Subject: [Users] Dependency data for OpenSAF Services > | | > | | All, > | | > | | Here is a description of the dependencies amongst the > | OpenSAF Services > | | which I think is useful for developers and users of the > | project. Note > | | some of these dependencies are bi-directional. (I am sure > | somebody can > | | turn this list into an exciting graph). > | | > | | 1. AvSv or the Availability Service which consists of SAF > AMF + SAF > | | CLM > | | + OpenSAF Availability Manager depends on: > | | - LEAP (OS Abstraction Layer ) > | | - Message Distribution Service or MDS > | | - Distributed Tracing Service or DTSv > | | - System Resource Monitoring Service or SRMSv > | | - Event Distribution Service or EDSv > | | - HPI Integration Service or HISv > | | - Management Access Service or MASv > | | - Persistence Store Service or PSSv > | | - Message Based Checkpointing Service or MBCSv > | | > | | 2. CPSv or the SAF Checkpoint Service depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv (Specifically AMF & CLM) > | | - MBCSv > | | - MASv > | | > | | 3. EDSv or the SAF Event Distribution Service depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv (AMF) > | | - MBCSv > | | - MASv > | | > | | 4. GLSv or the SAF Lock Service depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv > | | - MBCSv (for director redundancy) > | | - the SAF Checkpoint Service or the CPSv (for > node-director > | | redundancy) > | | > | | 5. MQSv or the SAF Message Service depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv (Specifically AMF & CLM) > | | - MBCSv > | | - MASv > | | > | | 6. HISv or Hardware Integration Service depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - EDSv > | | - HPI (but this is a pre-requisite as far as OpenSAF is > | | concerned) > | | > | | 7. Message Based Checkpointing Service or MBCSv > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | > | | 8. Interface Service or IFSv depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv > | | - MBCSv (for director redundancy) > | | - the SAF Checkpoint Service or the CPSv (for > node-director > | | redundancy) > | | - MASv > | | > | | 9. Management Access Service or MASv depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv > | | - MBCSv > | | > | | 10. Persistent Store Service or PSSv depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | > | | 11. System Resource Monitoring Service or SRMSv depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv > | | > | | 12. Distributed Trace Service or DTSv depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - MDS > | | - DTSv > | | - AvSv > | | - MBCSv > | | - MASv > | | > | | 13. Message Distribution Service depends on: > | | - LEAP > | | - Transport Layer, which today is TIPC. > | | > | | Thanks > | | Sayan > | | > | | > | > ______________________________________________________________________ > | | This email has been scanned by the MessageLabs Email > | Security System. > | | For more information please visit http://www.messagelabs.com/email > | | > | > ______________________________________________________________________ > | | _______________________________________________ > | | Users mailing list > | | Users@list.opensaf.org > | | http://list.opensaf.org/maillist/listinfo/users > | | > | | > | > ______________________________________________________________________ > | | This email has been scanned by the MessageLabs Email > | Security System. > | | For more information please visit http://www.messagelabs.com/email > | | > | > ______________________________________________________________________ > | | _______________________________________________ > | | Users mailing list > | | Users@list.opensaf.org > | | http://list.opensaf.org/maillist/listinfo/users > |> > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- > Version: GnuPG v1.4.7 (Darwin) > Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org > > iD8DBQFHvaWsf2Y/AQhD5IURArDfAKCI9rxNyhbUgkPvo5pMu5KcsVpW2wCfWYZw > WzZiONVi8CbUgRoSRuJysbI= > =A1Dx > -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- > ______________________________________________________________________ This email has been scanned by the MessageLabs Email Security System. For more information please visit http://www.messagelabs.com/email ______________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________ Users mailing list Users@list.opensaf.org http://list.opensaf.org/maillist/listinfo/users
