Sorry to piggy back on this subject, but since the topic has shifted to shale...

I am looking at using JBoss-Seam with Facelets as someone recommended
that it is built more for JSF/Facelets than Shale/Clay. The topic
didn't receive more discussion than that. I really don't know that
much about Shale & Clay.

Is there someone that has looking into both Seam and Shale? Are they
competitors or would they compliment each other? Also curious if using
Shale in JSF is a hack like trying to use Tiles in JSF (please don't
say that it isn't as working with Facelets is a drastic improvement -
like no ugly verbatim tags, and the ability to find components in
different pages from code which you can't in the JsfTiles view
handler).

Thanks in advance,
Andrew

On 11/10/05, Craig McClanahan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
>
> On 11/9/05, Sean Schofield <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > Yes Shale dialogs are very nice indeed :-)
>
>  I should mention an alternative approach that Shale enables as well ...
> putting the setup logic for a new view in the same page bean class as will
> process submits from this form.  The prerender() method provided by
> ViewController is perfect for this task.
>
>  If you like all the code related to the same page available in the same
> class, this approach will appeal to you.  If you like fine grained actions
> that can be composed together, the Dialogs approach will be more attractive.
>  Shale doesn't care which method you choose ... it helps you with either.
>
>  Craig
>
>

Reply via email to