Hi Hans, You say you are using "current myfaces with Sun RI". What does that mean? You can use *either* the myfaces JSF implementation *or* the Sun RI (Reference Implementation), but not both; they do exactly the same thing.
Perhaps you mean you're using myfaces-tomahawk on Sun RI? But I can't see any tomahawk tags in your example... The issue Dennis is referring to below only applies when using myfaces-tomahawk t:dataTable component with the Sun JSF implementation, which I don't *think* you're doing, though it's not entirely clear... Regards, Simon On Fri, 2006-01-13 at 00:01 +0000, Dennis Byrne wrote: > You may want to add your self as a watcher on this one. > > http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MYFACES-1010 > > Dennis Byrne > > >-----Original Message----- > >From: Hansjörg Meuschel [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > >Sent: Thursday, January 12, 2006 06:40 PM > >To: 'MyFaces Discussion' > >Subject: commandlink/button client-id bug > > > >Hi guys, > >the following jsf code: > > > ><h:form id="theForm"> > ><h:dataTable value="#{myBean.allXYBeans}" var="myBeanXYBean" id="table1"> > ><h:column> > ><h:dataTable value="#{myBeanXYBean.allZBeans}" var="ZBean" id="table2"> > ><h:column> > > <h:input type="text" value="#{ZBean.username}" id="username"/> > > <h:commandButton value="SAVE" action="#{ZBean.saveUsername}" > >id="savebutton"/> > ></h:column> > ></h:dataTable> > ></h:column> > ></h:dataTable> > ></h:form> > > > >--> all data can be submitted, but commandButton / commandlink > >components get identical client-ids: > > > >theForm:table1:savebutton > > > >--> very strange about this - the iteration on the text input is > >correctly done: [that's why the data can be submitted] > > > >theForm:table1:0:table2:username ... theForm:table1:6:table2:username > > > > > >Do you experience the same problem or is there any know bug? > >Any ideas for a workarround/bugfix ? > > > >Thanks for anyreplies! > > > >Regards, > >Hans > > > >PS. I'm using the current myfaces implementation with JSF RI 1.1.01 on > >apache tomcat 5 > > > > > > > >
