Hi Volker,
sorry, I can't reproduce it myself. But I'm really sure I've seen this.
If I see this behavior again I'll let you know.
Regards
Helmut
>Hi Helmut,
>
>i can't reproduce the differend behavior. Can you recheck this an post
>a code example if this exists with the current nightly?
>
>If your valueChangeListener was inside a button with immediate=true
>(e.g. inside a popup on such a button), there was a problem with the
>immediate of descendent commands (TOBAGO-262) but this should not
>affect valueChangeEvents.
>
>Regards,
> Volker
>
>
>2007/2/1, H. Swaczinna <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
>> Hello Volker,
>>
>> no, without ajax, the model is updated first and then the
>> valueChangeListener is called. And the bevaviour with ajax was
>> some days (snapshots) ago the same as without. So I build my
>> application code based on this behaviour ... :-(
>>
>> But yes, you're right, ValueChangeListeners should be fired in
>> validationPhase. So the baviour of Tobago (myFaces?) is inconsistent.
>>
>> Regards
>> Helmut
>>
>> >Hi Helmut,
>> >
>> >this is the correct behavior.
>> >
>> >ValueChangeListeners are fired in validationPhase (see jsf1.1 spec
>3.2.5.3),
>> >setters are executed in updateModelPhase.
>> >
>> >Should be the same as without ajax.
>> >
>> >Regards,
>> > Volker
>> >
>> >2007/2/1, H. Swaczinna <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
>> >> Hello,
>> >>
>> >> I've a selectBooleanCheckbox with a nested command tag with a
>> >> renderedPartially attribute. The selectBooleanCheckbox has a
>> >> valueChangeListener. The valueChangeListener should be called and
>> >> then some part of the page reloaded when the checkbox is clicked. This
>> >> works in general but the lifecycle sequence is not correct. The
>> >> valueChangeListener is called first and then the value is written back
>> >> to the model. It should be vice versa.
>> >>
>> >> JSP:
>> >>
>> >> <tc:panel id='panel'>
>> >> ...
>> >> <tc:selectBooleanCheckbox id="checkbox"
>> >> valueChangeListener="#{controller.valueChangeListener}"
>> >> value="#{controller.checkbox}">
>> >> <f:facet name="change">
>> >> <tc:command>
>> >> <tc:attribute name="renderedPartially"
>> >> value="panel"/>
>> >> </tc:command>
>> >> </f:facet>
>> >> </tc:selectBooleanCheckbox>
>> >> ...
>> >>
>> >> Java:
>> >>
>> >> public void valueChangeListener(ValueChangeEvent e) {
>> >> LOG.debug("valueChangeListener: " + e.getNewValue());
>> >> }
>> >>
>> >> public void setCheckbox(Boolean checkbox) {
>> >> LOG.debug("setCheckbox: " + checkbox);
>> >> }
>> >>
>> >> LOG:
>> >>
>> >> ...
>> >> controller - valueChangeListener: true
>> >> controller - setCheckbox: true
>> >> ...
>> >>
>> >>
>> >> Regards
>> >> Helmut
>> >>
>>
