2014-03-10 14:56 GMT-05:00 Karl Kildén <[email protected]>: > Ah the new release, yes I tried it asap it did not fix my issue. >
Which one? #1 or #2 ? > Regarding the duplicated id issue that I think could be related to > c:forEach, No idea what the problem is but it works fine with mojarra and > just as fine with myfaces 2.1.x. The construct in that app is special so it > is up to me to reproduce it and I don't have time until next week. And yes, > c:forEach works with ajax but it's important that the items are unchanged > during postback. > Ok. If we have an example we will be able to fix it more quickly. For now I'll take a look at MYFACES-3867 > I am considering mojarra because enctype="multipart/form-data" is not > working for me with any myfaces 2 version. It's common knowledge that > Mojarra is skimping on some validation here and there. > > > On 10 March 2014 20:13, Howard W. Smith, Jr. <[email protected]> wrote: > >> response inline, >> >> On Mon, Mar 10, 2014 at 2:43 PM, Karl Kildén <[email protected]> >> wrote: >> >> > Hi Howard, >> > >> > If someone proposed a fix for me I must have missed it, so no my issues >> are >> > still not resolved unfortunately. I don't think it's possible to write it >> > in another fashion. >> > >> >> Leonardo's response, asking you to try MyFaces 2.2.1, which was released >> within the last 12 to 24 hours. :) >> >> >> > >> > Problem #1: enctype="multipart/form-data" not working. Not sure if anyone >> > tried the demo app I linked in the jira but for now I can't investigate >> it >> > any further on my own. >> > >> >> i don't think Leonardo's response was targeting this issue. >> maybe/hopefully, Leonardo will respond at his earliest convenience. >> earlier, did you say that this issue is resolved via Mojarra 2.2.x (and >> some other container... glassfish, jboss, ...) ??? >> >> >> > >> > Problem #2 I also have a problem with duplicated id's but it would take >> > some time to reproduce it in a demo app so I'm hesitant to bring it up. >> > Basically a lot of ajax, dynamic includes, c:forEach, ui:repeat, some >> > bindings :-) >> > >> >> did you try MyFaces 2.2.1 release to see if the duplicated IDs issue is >> fixed in your app/project? >> >> is it best to assume that c:forEach is supposed to work with/via AJAX PPR? >> just because Mojarra 'works', should we assume that Mojarra's >> implementation is correct? >> >> MyFaces and TomEE committers know that there MyFaces may be a bit more >> 'strict' than Mojarra (I can agree with that as well, as per my experience >> when i migrated from Mojarra 2.1.x to MyFaces 2.1.x), and I think MyFaces >> (and TomEE) committers question the fact that Mojarra is really meeting >> requirements of the spec, or there is a different set of TCKs that Mojarra >> is running against. I hope 'they' will confirm, clarify, or correct what >> I'm stating here. :) >>
