Jdow said:
>>"I have found, in general, that whitelisting mailing lists
>>is not a very good idea" ... "I also find spams appear
>>on unmoderated Yahoo Groups." ... "a blanket white list of
>>the sort you propose would likely turn me white with anger"...

Thanks for the reply... but that is why I said in my original post:

>>"but without whitelisting other real spam"

Also, I'm more worried about SURBL (& other URI checker) hits on these than
rules hits.

Still, do you find such spam coming from those lists which are 100% opt-in?
If Yahoo 100% opt-in?

For the spam from Yahoo, is there a pattern? For example, I find that the
greatest risk for FPs are those instances where the list saves up a day's
worth of posts and then sends all of it in one e-mail.

Therefore, maybe a rule which considered ALL of the following would work: 

(1) sending server's IP
(2) MAILFROM
(3) size of the e-mail (maybe not including attachments), and
(4) > X number of e-mail addresses found in the body of the message.

Perhaps this kind of rule could whitelist the messages at highest risk of
being a FP message without whitelisting the occasional list spam?

Rob McEwen


Reply via email to