Random email that was forwarded to the customers Exchange server.. no way to debug... I just happened to notice it later...
The biggest thing is I see the HELO setup on mail servers incorrectly all the time, I didn't think SPF had anything to do with HELO... > Brian Taber wrote: >> Hmmm... Another potential SPF issue... I have a customer with AMEX, >> received an email from them, and the SPF checks conflict with each >> other: >> >> >> helo=<mta301.email.americanexpress.com> >> >> Received: from mta301.email.americanexpress.com >> (mta301.email.americanexpress.com [206.132.204.250]) >> >> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >> >> And the scores: >> 3.14 SPF_HELO_SOFTFAIL >> -0.00 SPF_PASS >> >> >> Why did the helo softfail? I tested their SPF record, and the test >> turned >> out a pass: >> >> http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/[EMAIL PROTECTED]&ip=206.132.204.250 >> >> >> Now I am really confused :) > > A debug output from SpamAssassin would probably tell you why or at least > help figure out why. > > Daryl > >