>> Has anyone else seen MIME spam that looks like:
>> 
>> ...
>> <a
>> href="http://www.paypalnetwork.info/us/cgi-bin/webscrcmd=_login+run/?logIN=upDate";>
>> https://www.paypal.com/us/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_login-run</a><br>
>> ...
>> 
>> Note that it looks like your clicking on the link
>> "https://www.paypal.com/...";
>> but in fact your really going to the spammers link...
>> 
>> I couldn't think of a regex to match these, so I guess you'd need to do
>> full-
>> fledged parsing of HTML in the message body.
>> 
>> Do these occur often enough to be worthwhile?
>> 
>> -Philip
>> 
>> 

Hi Philip,

most phish works that way so it is probably worthwhile...

This question comes up every now and then, and everytime there are a couple of 
responses
saying that many legitimate html mail contains similar stuff

<a href=somesite.com/buy.php?id=33>somesite.com/buy/dell_pc</a>
<a href=shop.somesite.com/buy.php?id=33>somesite.com/buy/dell_pc</a>

these would be okay for me and most others if the purported link works as well

<a href=somesite.com/buy.php?id=dt3hu93f6nk1zb>somesite.com/buy/dell_pc</a>

If it is a newsletter I signed up for, that could still be okay. Otherwise, I 
would expect that the
long id could be some sort of unwanted tracking

<a href=othersite.com/......>somesite.com/......</a>

Well it depends on whether I am willing to trust the relationship between the 
two sites:
- is othersite some service that could be contracted to do business for the 
visible site
(former state telecom, as an ISP, contracts an ad company to emailsuspicious  
newsletters
with encoded links ... it is just harmless spam)
- does othersite look related to somesite (e.g. same netblock or same whois 
information)

Well, my personal preference would be to mark all mail that does not meet the 
"same netblock"
(extended, if not the same /24, could still be same ARIN) not only with a few 
spam points
but with a thick red "THIS MAY BE PHISH" or even reject at the MTA
Of course, it would need many recipients blocking those or complaining, before 
senders
will start to understand that suspicious emails dont help but rather hinder 
their marketing efforts

Wolfgang Hamann



Reply via email to