Karsten Bräckelmann a écrit : > On Wed, 2009-05-27 at 09:21 +0200, Michael Monnerie wrote: >> On Mittwoch 27 Mai 2009 mouss wrote: >>> and 4454 is a one line message, but the signature causes the hit. > > The fact that mailing-list footer is forced onto the message with no > newline causes it. And the second hardly counts as human generated. ;) >
true, the guy replied without adding any personal comments. but these are things that happen: - I have a problem with foobar - what does /sbin/joe show - $joe_output now, the question is: what should really be caught? If I can suggest anything, I would like to propose the following: when a rule is designed: - document what it should catch - give examples of things it catches and things it shouldn't catch (so that if someone modifies the rule, he has some hints on what he can do) of course, if there's work to do, count me in (well, subject to my availability...). >> And my messages are just one-liners without .sig that should never hit >> this rule at all. > > Checked those samples from both of you. Lots more analysis of this eval > function added to the bug report. > > See comment 12. Smells kinda fishy to me, and probably broke at some > point since its original introduction. :/ > > >> I don't have other examples in original format, but just a few days ago >> got a FP report where this rule hit a normal, german, human-typed mail. >> I'll restore the original score now to see if I get more reports. > > Hmm, I'd love to see that one. Any *human-typed* mail featuring a real > sentence should not trigger this. Unless it's followed directly by a > huge machine-generated paste or something, without an empty line... > I'm not sure. but I'll have to dig in my mail before I can see anything real.
