Marc,
> >
> > Which fails when you have someone that has multiple domains that may be 
> > sending mail "from" the same organization. Mail to me from Citi may comes 
> > from any one of at least 6 different domains, and the mailserver is not 
> > necessarily in the same domain.
> >   
> Whitelist all 6 domains.
> >  

What if Citi starts using mail services from another provider with a
different ptr. Do you expect them to announce that on this mailing
list ? 
Conversely what if City stops services from one and then a
phisher/spammer buys of the server space. Thanks to the stupid whitelist
I will be sending all these spams whitelisted until we have angry  calls
on the customer support helpdesk.

This is useless for me to keep tracking what servers Citi ,Bank of
America, or ICICIBank  uses. I put just 1 line in my ".cf" file and
forget about it. Because their SPF record already keeps track. 

Even the largest banks today are outsourcing their email. FcRDNS works
only if the organization runs their own mailing and dont keep changing
their mailhost names. 


Thanks
Ram






Reply via email to