-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

Mark,

On 8/3/17 9:56 AM, Mark H. Wood wrote:
> I'm always surprised that so little mention is made of the Commons 
> Daemon approach:
> 
> http://tomcat.apache.org/tomcat-7.0-doc/setup.html#Unix_daemon
> 
> which, among other things, lets Tomcat get privileged ports the
> same way that HTTPD (like most other daemons) does: start
> privileged, acquire protected resources, drop privilege, run.
> 
> This *is* mentioned in RUNNING.txt, but somehow manages to be
> overlooked.

jsvc needs to be built on the target machine, etc. which adds another
layer of complexity (just like adding httpd would), which means that
you need a whole toolchain on the target box (or a similar box
elsewhere to build the library, then make sure you really have all the
dependencies)

For my money, I'd front Tomcat with something else, if only for
load-balancing and fail-over capabilities. If you have a reverse
proxy, the port number becomes irrelevant.

I only recently started really playing-around with Tomcat and TLS,
mostly for my Let's Encrypt presentation at this year's ApacheCon.

Given that I think a LB is appropriate, I've never bothered with TLS
and port number games on Tomcat[1].

- -chris

[1] ... although I *do* encrypt my AJP traffic between the web server
and Tomcat, using stunnel.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/
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=earS
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@tomcat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@tomcat.apache.org

Reply via email to