Use case: We implemented form-component-level feedback panels that we add to the components via borders -- though behaviors would be nicer and we may move to that. Then we ajaxily (sic) hide/display them beside or below the relevant components. Anything else that is form-level we display at the top of the form.
So we're really doing the same thing that the OP talks about, catching feedback at a more granular level where it's relevant. - Scott On 8/23/07, Eelco Hillenius <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > what we need to do is collect usecases from our users. > > Agreed. Users please give your say! > > > what you propose > > sounds great if you are doing component-hierarchy based filtering - but is > > this common. > > I think this is a natural way of thinking about it yeah. And I think > it is better than not doing filtering by default. > > > for example what about a usecase where there are two panels - > > one on top and one on bottom of a form showing the same messages - will we > > still support that? > > I didn't think of that, but that sounds like a valid use case yes. My > proposal however would only change the default, or make implementing > such hierarchy based filtering easier. I definitively like to keep the > filters etc and be compatible with what we have now if users want > that. > > > i would say ask our users for all these usecases, pick the most common ones > > but leave enough wiggle room to implement the uncommon ones. maybe really > > what we should do is not provide a feedbackpanel at all, but rather some > > callback that users can implement and build their own panels. > > I like feedback panel though. It's a very convenient component. We > could have variants or facilitate the use cases through configuration > the feedbackpanel. > > Eelco > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > -- Scott Swank reformed mathematician --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
