> I think I understand your explanations yet I struggle to see how scenario I
> was describing is optimization-only. Consider these scenarios:
>
> Shopping w/o signing in.
> 1.I go to amazon.com and fill my shopping cart with stuff without signing
> in.
> 2.I navigate away to somewhere else and short time later (< HttpSession
> timeout) type in 'amazon.com' to go back. At this point I'd still expect to
> see my cart's content.
>
> My Home Page is a portal
> 1. My home page is my.yahoo.com. When I launch my browser I get
> authenticated via a previously-stored cookie.
> 2.During the course of the same browser session I can navigate away to
> another site and then hit CTRL+H to go to my home page again.
> 3.As I land on my.yahoo.com seems that I am *not* re-authenticated from a
> persistent cookie - instead a cookie issued in #1 is used to locate my
> server-side state.
>
> In both of these scenarios NOT retrieving state from steps #1 is not merely
> a non-optimization - but
> unexpected behavior. Do you agree?

No I don't. This is where bookmarkable pages are meant for. In both
cases you would use cookies, and these bookmarkable pages read the
cookies to determine what's in the cart.

Eelco

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to