Vincent Massol wrote: > On Apr 2, 2009, at 1:22 AM, Marius Dumitru Florea wrote: > >> hel-o wrote: >>> Hi, >>> >>> >>> >>> To remove the list formatting you can either use the outdent button >>> from >>> the tool bar or place the caret before "item1" and press Shift+Tab. >>> >>> The behavior you describe can be reproduced also in the default >>> editor ( >>> http://www.mozilla.org/editor/midasdemo/ ) and I think it is the >>> correct >>> one. It may not be natural at first look, but consider the following >>> example: >>> >>> >>> >>> Dont know but just tried openoffice and there you remove list >>> formatting with the list formatting butten and change the indent of >>> the list with the outdent button. >> Yes, I know, but the fact that Open Office has this behavior doesn't >> necessarily mean it is the best one. You can open an issue and if >> others >> share your opinion then we'll have to change the current behavior. My >> worry is that the current behavior is useful in some cases and we >> could >> loose this advantage. >> >>> >>> >>>> 3. When you undo the list formating and redo the list formating a >>>> paragraph is added between the two list items >>>> >>>> - item1 >>>> >>>> - item2 >>> I need more input on this. How do you get the list in the first >>> place? >>> >>> >>> >>> i had an list with two items >>> >>> - item1 >>> - item2 > > step1 > >>> >>> removed the list formatting with the list formatting button >>> >>> item1 >>> >>> - item2 > > step2 > >>> >>> and changed the formatting to list formatting again >>> >>> - item1 >>> >>> - item2 > > step3 > >> This is somehow normal because you have created two lists. Now, I >> can't >> think of a reason why the user would want the two lists to be >> separated >> so I think they should be automatically merged into a single list with >> two items. Can you open an issue for this? > > I'm not sure about this one. The current behavior sounds right to me. > It sounds a bit too "magic"' to me to merge them automatically and I'm > sure there are use case where you can have 2 lists one after another. > This is valid in wiki syntax and we need that to be valid in the > wysiwyg editor too. > > More precisely step2 sounds correct to me since the user is making the > item outside of the list so you need the new line since it becomes a > para when you do this. > > I'm quite against step3 if we were to automatically merge two lists > one after another. We could have a join shortcut/icon for joining > lists (although hitting suppr when placed at the end of item1 should > do the same).
I agree: http://jira.xwiki.org/jira/browse/XWIKI-3488 Thanks, Marius > > Thanks > -Vincent > >> Thanks, >> Marius >> >>> tried that with the outdent button too, same behavior. also tried >>> it in the default editor mentioned above, same behavior. but theres >>> one difference, if i remove the paragraph (line break) what ever in >>> XWiki i get >>> >>> - item1item2 >>> >>> In the mentioned editor i get >>> >>> - item1 >>> - item2 >>> >>> hel. >>> >>> ----- >>> hel. >>> h...@hel.at > _______________________________________________ > users mailing list > users@xwiki.org > http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/users _______________________________________________ users mailing list users@xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/users
