Jim Elwell wrote in USMA 20264:

>However, the last paragraph of Louis' post brings up a very important
>point: since when is a government supposed to impose things that are not
>supported by the population, and how is that any different than tyranny?
>
>Such statements make me want to equate liberal = tyrannical.


It is important to distinguish between two conceptions of democracy.  A
representative votes for what he perceives to be the wishes of his
constituents. The US constitution, with its division of powers between the
executive and the legislative branches, favors this concept.

The British tradition does not have this division.  Members of Parliament
are expected to vote for what they perceive to be in the best interests of
the country and their constituents.  They are delegates and not
rpresentatives.

Joseph B.Reid
17 Glebe Road West
Toronto  M5P 1C8             Tel. 416 486-6071

Reply via email to