At 21 08 05, 08:51 AM, Jon Saxton wrote:
>The majority of $1 bills are printed as replacements for worn or damaged ones 
>and no seignorage is earned on those.   Coins may cost about 3 times as much 
>to produce but their lifetimes are measured in decades rather than months and 
>the net cost per unit is a lot less.

95% of bills are replacements, so the government actually has to pay six cents 
for 19 our of 20 bills, and gets nothing in return.

That said, Daniel's description of "seigniorage" is incorrect, as any 
freshmen-level macroeconomics text will explain. A bill is nothing but a 
promissary note. If I take my $100 paycheck to the bank and exchange it for 
dollar bills, I give them a piece of paper that says my employer will give the 
holder $100, I get 100 pieces of paper that are each worth $1 in goods. If 
Daniel's "seigniorage" were correct, I'm getting the better deal: one piece of 
paper for 100 pieces of paper.

Jim




Jim Elwell, CAMS
Electrical Engineer
Industrial manufacturing manager
Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
www.qsicorp.com

Reply via email to