I can certainly back Eugene up in his proposal for "best practice".  In the
UK the law requires that most unit prices be per kilogram. This is not
always enforced. Many supermarkets, especially on the delicatessen and
confectionary counters, have a mix of unit pricing "per kilogram" and "per
100 g". At least it is easy to convert between the two in order to compare
"like with like" and certainly a lot easier than "per pound" and "per
quarter".   

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf
Of mechtly, eugene a
Sent: 29 April 2014 01:33
To: U.S. Metric Association
Cc: Kenneth Butcher; David Sefcik
Subject: [USMA:53764] Links to Mandated Unit Pricing

Five of the ten "Directors of Legal Metrology" (or their representatives,
usually in departments of agriculture) have now sent me links to their
respective "current" Laws or Regulations or Rules mandating Unit Pricing.  

These Rules apply in Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, or
Vermont, respectively.

Connecticut, New Jersey, Oregon, Rhode Island, and DC have yet to send links
to their *current* Laws or Regulations, or Rules on Unit Pricing, although
these five jurisdictions are also believed to mandate Unit Pricing.

Maryland, in particular, mandates Unit Pricing, and *permits* metric or
not-metric units in the denominators of Unit Price.

On the other hand, Massachusetts and New York , mandate Unit Pricing, but
*require* not-metric units in the denominators of Unit Price; such as (per
fluid ounce), (per pint), (per quart) or (per gallon)!

This malpractice from the 19th Century persists in the present, and hampers
value comparisons as noted by John Steele in his study of all 50+
jurisdictions in the United States, as of 2009.

"Best Practice" clearly requires units in the denominators of Unit Price,
that are related by multiples of ten, for easy comparisons of value by
mental arithmetic.  Examples: grams or milligrams; liters or milliliters,
and meters or millimeters.

Mandating units outside the SI (such as fluid ounces, pints, quarts,
gallons) *does not* accomplish this service to buyers of consumer
commodities and constitutes "Worst Practice" as in the words of John Steele.


Eugene Mechtly
  


Reply via email to