*USMA members will, I hope, be pleased reading the answer to an editor who
desired that American units be presented alongside the SI values in
my manuscript. *

*Dear ....*
*I attempted the parenthesis you suggested but found the resulting
complexity of the text disruptive and harder to read. And there are other
problems associated with doubling each unit.  Allow me a few words of
explanation.*



*The article is about comparing two sets of numbers. For that, there need
not be any unit at all. The majority of readers will skip the units anyway,
and the few curious engineers and physics teachers will know how to convert
to whatever units they like. As to the several common values I doubt that
there are readers that wouldn't know that water freezes at 0 deg. Celsius
or what a km is. As to the substitution for the one still unfamiliar unit –
the joule or MJ – here Americans use several different units for energy
such as calorie, Btu, kilowatt hour, lb-ft. As a result. I am at a loss
which one to select. Different professions** use them all – that would be
four parentheses. Instead, I spelled out the symbol MJ and use it
consistently thereafter. Thus no problem with comparing numbers. In any
case  non-technical readers will not care, and experts who might be
checking the math will convert the value to whichever unit they like. I am
pleased to say that, up to now, **no publisher asked me to add conversions.
Dozens of articles, no complains. May I say that one might underestimate
one’s readers?*



*As a side issue, you may be interested in why I insist on the units of a
system that has only one unit for any measurement, be it energy, power, or
length. That’s because, with the multiplicity of the U.S. energy and power
units, it is common to present false or misleading numbers and get away
with it for it is too difficult and bothersome for readers to look up all
the conversion factors to check. I might also point out that since it is
the Federal Law and Exec. Order that state that "SI metric is the preferred
measurement system in the **U.S.**" my writing in SI only should help
citizens learning it. Once they see how **easy comparisons are with SI
units, they might actually prefer that system particularly when noticing
the cheating in the daily press with American units such as the one
illustrated in the other enclosed treatise. *

*Yours,*

*Stan Jakuba*

Reply via email to