Sent from my iPhone
> On Nov 20, 2015, at 7:53 AM, Stephen Farrell <[email protected]> > wrote: > > > Hiya, > > Sorry for being slow getting this done. My AD review of this > is below. Please consider my comments as last call comments. > I have requested last call for this one so you should see the > announcement of that shortly. > > - section 3, first list, bullet 1: what's option (c) there mean? > wasn't clear to me. > > - typo: "an email server certificates" > > - section 3, 2nd list, bullet 3 - is that MUST NOT really needed? if > URIs are not used, might it be better to be silent? (In case someone > does figure out a use?) > > - section 3, 2nd list, bullet 4 - afaik, CN is what is mostly > actually used. Shouldn't we recognise that reality with more than a > MAY? It's been more than a decade since PKI folks started to want to > not use CN and that's just not worked. (Or am I wrong and CAs/MUAs > are finally seeing CN not used?) Hmm, they were used in all of the CAs I set up and certificates I have needed to use, adding the host name there. Sometimes there were CNAMEs added in an extension. What are you seeing used instead of CN/DN? > > - section 4, bullets 1&2 - do we have any evidence that these MUSTs > will be honoured? If not, or if we have eveidence that they will be > ignored, then is it really a good idea to include such RFC6919-isms? > (A change here would also percolate to sections 3 and 5 I guess.) > > - I think the answer is "no," but I'll ask anyway:-) Many mail > service providers use names like mail.example.com, smtp.example.com, > imap.example.com etc. Would it be useful for this document to > encourge the use of specific hostname parts for specific functions? > (Hostname part is probably the wron term, I mean the smtp, imap, > mail parts of those names) > > Cheers, > S. > > _______________________________________________ > Uta mailing list > [email protected] > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/uta _______________________________________________ Uta mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/uta
