On Fri, 2004-03-05 at 13:57, Jason Holt wrote:
> [...]
> >     var final_to_encode = passwd_enc + form.one_time_token.value;
> >     form.encoded_pw.value = calcMD5(final_to_encode);
> [...]
> 
> > This way the password cannot be "sniffed" and the page is not
vulnerable
> > to a replay attack.
> 
> Firstly, you'd lose to any kind of active attack, which isn't too much
harder
> than passively listening.
> 
> But secondly, no, replay is still possible.  form.one_time_token.value
> corresponds to the output of calcMD5, so I just replay both values.
Keeping
> track of which value you specified on the server side can help, but is
also
> trouble-prone

As for the one time token, PHP creates the token on the server before
the page is sent to the client and stores it in a SESSION variable,
(this site uses no COOKIES, all server side sessions) then the token is
sent to the client where it is hashed with the password, the sent
encrypted back to server where the server compares newly received hash
to the users password stored in the DB and the token in the Session
variable.  If it passes the test then the authenticating Session is
DESTROYED and a new AUTHENTICATED session is created.

I know that it's all still vulnerable to a man-in-the middle attack at
this point but my goal is to keep the password safe during the
authentication process. 


FYI I'm working on two projects one that Just needs the hashed password
sent like described above,   

The second is a problem where I need to send the password encrypted to
the server, but then the Server has to decrypt that password and send it
plain text to an LDAP server I'm not too worried about the link between
the server and the LDAP server, the traffic between my server and LDAP
is all in the datacenter, the only way to sniff the packets is if you
were in the datacenter listening. 

Thank you again for everyone's input on this project I'm learning a lot
about encryption.

Mark Gardner


____________________
BYU Unix Users Group
http://uug.byu.edu/
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list

Reply via email to