I chose SuSE over Mandrake for several reasons:

1. I thought that YaST was much better than the configuration tools in Mandrake.  The 
deciding factor was actually their package manager, which I felt beat Mandrake hands 
down.  I also like that YaST works just as well from the command-line as it does in X. 
 I didn't have any trouble with updates in SuSE; it must have been a mirror problem 
you had.  I have acutally encountered that before.

2. It came with a TON of packages (5 CD's).  Mandrake seemed to be a little lacking in 
that area (3 CD's).  At the time Mandrake didn't have URPMI (that's the APT 
equivalent, right?) so I had trouble getting the packages I wanted.  Now Mandrake have 
URPMI, and SuSE doesn't have an equivalent.  So... That argument may be invalid now. 
(That's one of the reasons I am thinking of trying Mandrake)

3. I didn't have any trouble getting the free version of SuSE.  At Novell, I can get 
those ISO's before it is even oficially released.  If you would like some help in this 
area, I may be able to assist.

4. I liked SuSE's artwork much better.

6. SuSE's hardware support was better.  I could not get Mandrake to detect my USB 
hardware for the life of me.

7. I generally felt that SuSE was much better evolved than Mandrake.

Feedback on these comparisons would be appreciated.

Kirk Coombs


-----Original Message-----
From: Bryan Murdock <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: BYU Unix Users Group <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Date: Wed, 17 Mar 2004 17:17:46 -0800
Subject: Re: [uug] Mandrake vs. SuSE

On Wed, 2004-03-17 at 15:57, Kirk Coombs wrote:
> I have been using SuSE linux for some time, and really enjoy it. (I am
>  currently using 9.0 and 9.0x64).  Mandrake was the first distro I
>  used, and I thought it was pretty good, but I liked SuSE better. 
>  (I've tried them all -- Red Hat, Gentoo, Debian, etc.  I did like
>  Gentoo, but I went with SuSE b/c I work at Novell) It has been a few
>  releases since I have taken a look at it.  With the upcoming release
>  of SuSE 9.1 (kernel 2.6, KDE 3.2, etc), I will be re-installing my
>  OS.  I was wondering what everybody's opinion of Mandrake VS SuSE is. 
>  I am considering giving Mandrake 10 and 10x64 a try.

I've been using Mandrake for a while, and I tried Suse 9.0 not too long
ago.  I feel like I gave it a pretty fair shake, though part of my
deciding to stick with Mandrake, I'll admit, probably was just because
I didn't want to learn new ways to do stuff that I could already do in
Mandrake.  I also don't have to wait as long for the free version with
Mandrake :)

Anyway, Suse has a nice "control center" gui like Mandrake that allows
you to easily do stuff like software updates, configure services, set up
printers and stuff.  Suse's seemed nicer at first, but I had a heck of a
time getting the software updator to work right.  May have just been the
mirror I was trying to talk to.  Anyway, the two are very similar.  I
can't say one is better than the other too objectively, because I'm just
more used to Mandrake's.  Not being able to get software updates to
work, gui or command-line, was a real bummer for me in Suse.

I like how you can get the plf mirror in your software sources for
Mandrake and very easily get dvd playing set-up.  I could not for the
life of me get that to work in a similar manner in Suse, and even when
I thought I had installed the codecs whenever I tried to play a DVD a
message would pop up and say something like, "sorry, you just can't
play commercial dvd's in Linux."  I don't know if Suse is just being
extra careful, or trying to protect me from "breakin' the law" or what,
but that bugged.

Something else about Mandrake in general that I love is that you can
generally find Mandrake rpm's for anything on the web.  I would say even
more than Redhat (though I have no real proof).  I'll admit I did
compile some stuff from source the other day, but that was the first
time I'd needed to do that in a really long time.  I don't know if Suse
has that kind of benefit or not.

In general Suse really impressed me.  Their default KDE setup was really
impressive.  The installer was nice.  The control center is great.
Their not-so-subtle jabs at Microsoft are awesome.  If it turns out it
does have a quick command line tool like apt, yum, or urpmi that works,
and some good repositories out there, and you can get DVD's to play,
then I'm sure it's just as good or maybe better than Mandrake as a
distro overall.

I'm curious to hear what you liked better about Suse when you made your
comparison.

Bryan

P.S. Sorry I'm too lazy to type SuSE every time, if that's what's
proper.


____________________
BYU Unix Users Group
http://uug.byu.edu/
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list


[EMAIL PROTECTED]
www.kirkcoombs.us

"To err is human... to really foul up requires the root password."

____________________
BYU Unix Users Group
http://uug.byu.edu/
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list

Reply via email to