Hi, I support graduation. The project has a good group of supporters, and has demonstrated continued growth over time. It's a stable project, and should graduate.
In the future, I hope it becomes easier to install and maintain (i.e. yum package management). I've been looking into what it would take to post it to EPEL. After graduation, this seems like a natural progression. Also, after meeting with representatives from other campuses, I found that they really had a problem configuring VCL the first time (Most of the off campus calls I receive about VCL were asking for help configuring VCL. In particular, what equipment to use, how to setup DHCP, how to configure Shibboleth, how to make it work under windows - as for the last one, please don't!). If there had been some examples of actual equipment configurations, and some screen shots of configuration pages, it would have been nice. IMHO, it think it would be helpful to setup a demo system on the VCL website. Just to help people who haven't had any exposure to VCL get an idea what to expect. From what I've experienced, people want to compare it to things like Citrix, but give up because they have trouble setting up a test bed. Just my 2 cents worth, __Jim O'Dell On 5/1/2012 9:44 AM, Andy Kurth wrote: > This thread is to discuss whether the Apache VCL community feels that > this incubating project is ready to proceed with the process to > graduate to a top level ASF project. There are several requirements > which must be met and steps completed in order to graduate. This > discussion thread is the first step towards graduation. Please review > the following pages. > http://incubator.apache.org/guides/graduation.html > http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Graduating+from+the+Incubator > > There are many items described in the ASF graduation documentation > which we have obviously satisfied (create a release, etc). The > following are issues that I feel either need to be addressed, would be > concerned about regarding board/mentor approval, or have been brought > up before. Please share your thoughts. Also, please review the ASF > graduation documentation and bring up anything else which might be a > concern. > > Status File: > (https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/public/trunk/content/projects/vcl.xml) > This is not up to date and is missing information. Previous board > reports need to be added. News items need to be added containing the > string "new committer". Doing this will cause the numberCommittersNew > column on the "Status of the Clutch" page to turn green > (http://incubator.apache.org/clutch.html). > > Also, the list of commiters in the status file and project page hasn't > changed since Apache VCL started. The new committers obviously need > to be added. I'm not sure how the original list was decided upon, but > I feel several names should be removed since they have not contributed > any code and some have not been involved in the community at all. I > think the list should be Aaron Coburn, David Hutchins, Andy Kurth, > James O'Dell, Aaron Peeler, Josh Thompson. Also, Brian Bouterse > contributed some code a while ago. I'm not sure if he is still > interested in being a committer. > > Diversity: > ASF requirement: "The project is not highly dependent on any single > contributor (there are at least 3 legally independent committers and > there is no single company or entity that is vital to the success of > the project)." > This issue has been raised before. I feel we meet this requirement > and that the community is generally diverse, can govern itself, and be > self-sufficient. > > Website: > This is not necessarily a requirement for graduation but I feel that > it should be addressed prior to graduation. Our website/documentation > is pretty rough and really should be redesigned. I'm guessing the > board members will look at it prior to voting. In addition, there > will likely be a press release if/when we graduate and website views > will spike. This shouldn't hold up the graduation process, but I > would like agreement that this should be completed by graduation. > > Thank You, > Andy -- Jim O'Dell Network Analyst California State University Fullerton Email: jod...@fullerton.edu Phone: (657) 278-2256