FYI

In the comments on a short TechCrunch review (http://tinyurl.com/2bcqx5) about 
VLIP i 
read the following provocative statements:

'Erick' writes:

"Unless a person is at least the slightest bit entertaining, Vlogging stinks. I 
dont want to 
look at some weirdo sitting at home/work talking into a webcam about their lame 
day or 
skill or opinion. If you arent as entertaining as Ze Frank, then you stink and 
nobody wants 
to hear/see you..."

and David Scott Lexis writes:

"Video blogs have been a failure, as I noted in a couple of AlwaysOn Network 
columns. 
Videos are one thing; automatically downloading video blogs (or video podcasts; 
I prefer 
"video podcasts") is too bandwidth intensive, too slow, takes up too much hard 
disk space.

You want to leave your computer on all night to download video podcasts? Well, 
good for 
you … but you're in the minority. How many video podcasts have been successful? 
Do any 
have over 10,000 subscribers to their feed?

Compare and contrast with "standard" blogs — such as this one. Matter of fact, 
are there 
any video podcasts that have even 1% of the subscribers that TechCrunch has? 
None that 
I'm aware of, and in my public blogroll I subscribe to a lot 
(http://www.bloglines.com/
public/DSL).

Mind you, this might be a decent idea, but until bandwidth, hard disk space and 
all sorts 
of other limitations are overcome (like the need for better and easier 
production 
techniques), it will remain a novelty for the SXSW crowd (and they're not early 
adopters, 
they're "way-too-early adopters"; in the 70's they would have been touting the 
wonders of 
AI).

BTW, I still subscribe to several video podcasts for my iPod. But I suspect 
that I'm in the 
minority; I know very few people outside of the Bay area who subscribe to more 
than a few 
(if any) — and I don't know anyone in China (where I currently live) who 
subscribes to any 
… not even one. YouTube, thumbs up; video blogs & video podcasts, thumbs down 
(too 
early).

Remember, so-called and self-anointed pioneers usually wind up with arrows in 
their 
back. Besides, how many people really have good "TV"/video presence? Not a lot. 
Good 
podcasters are a subset of good bloggers, but good vloggers are a subset of 
good 
podcasters: That's a tiny set..."



Reply via email to