Martin Krischik wrote:
But do we need an id? - each tip will have a page name which will be unique.
IMHO you are correct - we should NOT have a tip id. I'm not sure what is feasible, but here is my ideal: - Import current tip_nr into the template. - Display tip_nr near the top of the tip, very modestly. - When we're ready to abandon ids, stop displaying tip_nr.
"Content first" is makes Wikis successfull. The "Vim Wiki" project is talking to much about ID numbers, templates, organization etc. pp. without producing any content.
You're talking a lot of sense, Martin. However, someone is going to import 1500 tips, so I can put up with a bit more planning. But if there's no action before June, I think it would be reasonable to despair<g>. John
