There are a lot of people here who can comment on this. As I see it, the quality of information is very different. They are both good for identifying things but they are different.
Digit-Eyes only works on things with codes. The code can be the one that the manufacturer put there or it can be one that you put there. It is going to be considerably more precise. Here is a useful review (and I'm going to quote from it a bit as an example) http://www.afb.org/afbpress/pub.asp?DocID=aw130404 AFB used VizWiz and Digit-Eyes. ================================================= test 1 -===================================== This test item was a can of healthy choice tomato basic soup: VizWiz Ten minutes elapsed between the time the "Send" button was activated and the results were reviewed. Image: A can of Healthy Choice Tomato Basil Soup received two responses. Question: "What's in this can?" IQ Engines said: "Healthy Choice Soup" A Web worker said: ""This is a health drink. It is useful for heart." Digit-Eyes response takes about 1 second. The results were: This item is:Healthy Choice Tomato Basic SoupMade by:ConAgra Foods, Inc.Issued in:United StatesSize/Weight:15 oz (425 g)Ingredients:*Ingredients: *Water, Tomato Puree (Water, Tomato Paste), Sugar, Mirepoix Base (Sauteed Vegetable [Carrot, Celery, Onions], Sugar, Soybean Oil, Salt, Maltodextrin, Modified Corn Starch, Natural Flavoring), Modified Corn Starch, Less than 2% of: Basil, Salt, Onion Powder, Citric Acid, Garlic Powder, Natural Flavoring.Manufacturer's Information: *Directions:* Ovens vary - cooking time and temperature may need adjustment. Do not add water. Microwave: 1. Microwave in covered microwave-safe container on High power 2 minutes or until hot. 2. Let stand 1 minute in microwave. 3. Stir before serving. Stove Top: Heat over Medium heat in saucepan until hot, stirring occasionally. *Product Details:* Heart healthy (While many factors affect heart disease, diets low in saturated fat and cholesterol may reduce the risk of this disease). 130 calories; 470 mg sodium per serving. 10% of daily vegetables. USDA daily recommended amounts: 2-1/2 cups vegetables. One Serving Contains: 1/4 cup (10%) vegetables. Based on a 2000-calories diet. Balance calories with physical activity. Contains no MSG (Except for the small amount naturally occurring in autolyzed yeast extract). Weight Watchers Points = 2 per serving (Weight Watchers and Points are registered trademarks of Weight Watchers International, Inc. The number of Points provided here was calculated by ConAgra Foods based on published Weight Watchers International, Inc., information and does not imply sponsorship or endorsement of such number of Points or of Healthy Choice products by Weight Watchers International, Inc). Diet Exchanges Per Serving: 1 carbohydrate. Diet exchanges are based on Exchange Lists for Meal Planning, copyright 2003 by the American Diabetes Assoc., Inc. and the American Dietetic Assoc.Nutrition Facts *Serving size:* 1 cup *Servings per container:* 2 NutrientQty%DVCalories130 Calories from Fat5 Total Fat0.5 g1%Cholesterol5 mg1%Sodium470 mg20%Total Carbohydrate28 g9%Dietary Fiber3 g12%Sugars12 g Protein4 g Vitamin A 8%Calcium 2%Iron 4%Is or Contains Flavor ServingSize-InGrams250 g http://www.amazon.com/ ... /B003DWD7W0<http://www.amazon.com/Healthy-Choice-Tomato-Basil-Soup/dp/B003DWD7W0> More information: www.amazon.com<http://www.amazon.com/Healthy-Choice-Tomato-Basil-Soup/dp/B003DWD7W0> ================================================= test 2 -===================================== VizWiz response: Image: A can of Diet Coke received one response. Question: "What's in this can?" IQ Engines said: "Diet Coke" Digit-Eyes response: This item is:Coca-cola Cola (diet) - Heart Flag - The Heart Truth - 0 Calories PerIssued in:United StatesSize/Weight:355mLIngredients:* Ingredients: *Carbonated Water, Caramel Color, Aspartame, Phosphoric Acid, Potassium Benzoate (To Protect Taste), Natural Flavors, Citric Acid, Caffeine.Manufacturer's Information: *Product Details:* Very low sodium. *Warnings:* Contains: Phenylalanine.Nutrition Facts *Serving size:* 1 can *Servings per container:* 1 NutrientQty%DVSodium40 mg2% ================================================= test 3 -===================================== VizWiz Image: Brown, white, and off-white animal print blouse Question: "What does this blouse look like?" received three responses. Web workers said: "A cloth of some kind." Another Web worker: "Like a tiger skin." IQ Engines said "Animal print." Digit-Eyes would not have identified this item without a label; if it had the label, the content would be whatever the person who owns the blouse had recorded. The AFB reviewer concludes: The Bottom Line All of these apps can be very useful for someone with a visual impairment. Since VizWiz is free, it's worth putting on your device. If you can afford it, I'd get both Digit-Eyes and LookTel Recognizer. No app is perfect, but these three apps can make identification much easier. So I think the answer is "the results are different and both can be useful" Other people may have other opinions. Incidentally, VizWiz is free because it is a research project and it is funded by grants (your tax dollars at work!) Digit-Eyes is for sale because it is the product of several programmers working together who need to support themselves and their families. On Monday, May 7, 2012 5:01:33 PM UTC-5, Brenth wrote: > > I wonder, what would really be better about getting this app than using > Vizwiz to scan stuff? I understand Vizwiz is just a research project that > could go away to tell what kinds of visual info blind people want access > to. It probably wouldn't tell me how to actually cook that pizza, even if > their engine identifies what kind it was. > > > > > ----- Original Message ----- > *From:* Nancy M <[email protected]> > *To:* [email protected] > *Sent:* Monday, May 07, 2012 1:18 PM > *Subject:* Re: Finding Bar Codes > > This is a very good question~ > > Some bottles have codes and some do not. If you ever want to confirm, > you can send us an image of what you are scanning. Just tap the link at > the bottom of the scanning screen titled 'send picture' and it will format > a mail to us that contains a picture. You can add a note with a question > like "does this item even HAVE a barcode?" and we will have someone get > back to you and let you know. If it is something with two sides like a > round bottle with a label that goes all round it, please try to send > images of both sides. > > We do have a lot of codes (26,195,585 as of this writing), but we won't > have everything. I see we just added an expandamonium flexfit hat, > whatever that may be .. but we won't necessarily have all local codes. > > The database does, however, grow with time and it is designed to grow in > direct relationship to its usage. > > Digit-Eyes is (in part) a search engine that specializes in UPC and EAN > codes. We get our information in the same way that Google or any other > search engine does -- we have special computer programs (sometimes called > "bots" or "spiders") that crawl the world wide web and get information from > manufacturer's and retailer's websites. This information includes UPC / EAN > codes and is used to provide the results to people who scan and to provide > links to the original sources so that you can find out more about the > product. > > We have about a 95% hit rate for new users who are just starting up, which > sounds great (and is many time more than other products). But it still > means that about 1 in 20 items won't be found. > > When this occurs, two things happen: > > 1. You are given a chance to enter the name of the product if you know > it. This is immediately added to the database and becomes available to you > and all other users. Sometime later that day, added content will be > checked > by our staff and the number added to the list of codes to be searched for > additional information by our spiders. Having the title of the item is > useful and will improve the probability of obtaining page links that > you'll > be able to access later. > 2. All failed codes go into a special high-priority search queue that > is used to direct the spiders to look for information about that code. > When > the information is found, it is added to the database so it is ready for > you next time you scan the item. > > The practical effect of this is that it is fairly common that find within > 24 hours or so that the code that was previously not found is now in the > database. > > And because the database is online and dynamic, it means that the more you > scan, the more likely the system is to find things in your area of the > country and the fewer things you will have that won't be found. > > So in the case of Orb's pizza, when you scan one and it is not found, add > the name. That way it will be there next time you scan. Meanwhile, the > spiders will be looking for nutritional information, ingredients, and other > links that will be of use to you next time you have one. > > There are cases where nothing will be found because the item is simply not > listed on the Internet. And there are times when we won't be able to get > extended information for the same reason. But there are many MANY cases > where it will be found and where data provided to you will become more > useful and richer over time. > > > On Monday, May 7, 2012 11:25:26 AM UTC-5, AyrakCMH wrote: >> >> Nancy, I purchased D-E last night. Playing around with it, I tried a >> bottle >> of aspirin. I could not find a code on the bottle. >> >> I just wonder, since these products generally come packaged inside a box, >> are there bar codes on the bottle, too? I have not yet had anyone look at >> the bottle to see if one is there or not. >> >> I did try a food can and eventually found the code on it, scanning in the >> same place and same lighting, but it could not identify the product. I >> have >> not yet read all of the training material, but it seemed kind of odd I >> would >> have anything in my pantry not fairly commonly available all around the >> country, unless maybe private store brand items are not as much available >> in >> the database? >> >> I am looking forward to learning and using this. All thanks! >> >> Eric >> >> >> >> -- > You received this message because you are subscribed to the "VIPhone" > Google Group. > To search the VIPhone public archive, visit > http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/. > To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. > To unsubscribe from this group, send email to > [email protected]. > For more options, visit this group at > http://groups.google.com/group/viphone?hl=en. > > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the "VIPhone" Google Group. To search the VIPhone public archive, visit http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected]. For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/viphone?hl=en.
