AI Weekly: Why this Apple loyalist isn't springing for a HomePod . yet
By Blair Hanley, February 2, 2018 10:17 AM

I have a confession to make: Even though I'm typing this on a MacBook Pro
while wearing an Apple Watch and listening to Apple Music through a pair of
Beats X headphones, I haven't preordered the HomePod. I had one in my
shopping cart the first day it was available for purchase. I really did. But
I just couldn't pull the trigger and pay $350 for Apple's new smart speaker.

The HomePod just doesn't do enough to justify its price, especially for
someone who already has a couple Google Home devices sitting around his
apartment. But even if I didn't have any smart speakers yet, I don't think
I'd spring for Apple's latest offering.

It's missing features that Apple promised, chief among them support for
multiple users. Like many people, I share my apartment with a roommate. And
while I enjoy his company quite a bit, I don't want to give him access to a
digital assistant with all of my calendar information that can send text
messages in my stead.

I also have little use for a high-fidelity smart speaker in a relatively
small apartment where I don't feel like treating my neighbors to all of my
musical taste. The Google Home Max, which is arguably the HomePod's closest
competitor, was overkill for the space that I have.

Roll all of that together, along with Siri's lack of killer features
compared to its competition, and I think it's fairly easy to see why the
HomePod is a tough sell, even for a hard-core Apple product user.
But before everyone fires up their hot takes about how APPLE IS DOOMED, it's
worth noting that we're still very much in the early days of the virtual
assistant wars. As it stands, none of the companies with a virtual assistant
currently on the market lives up to its ideal self. What's more, Apple has
strong lock-in to keep hard-core users from jumping ship away from Siri.

After all, it's not like I'm about to bail on my Apple Watch and iPhone just
to be closer to the Google Assistant, nor is Apple going to allow it to act
like a first-class citizen on the company's mobile platforms. If it takes
Apple a year to make the HomePod something worth purchasing, it'll still be
worth my money.

This is a market where Apple still has a chance to thrive - after all, it
was late to the media player market with the iPod, the smartphone market
with the iPhone, the tablet market with the iPad, and the smartwatch market
with the Apple Watch. And yet the company has gone on to hold dominant
positions in all four, despite charging higher prices for its flagship

(There are, of course, counterexamples, like Apple's relatively weak
position in the smart home space relative to hardware that connects with
Amazon's Alexa smart speaker.)

Apple can also improve the HomePod through software updates, without new
hardware revisions, and the company has said the speaker will receive some
of its missing features through updated firmware later this year. It's
unclear how much longer that's going to take, though. Knowing Apple, such
updates could come within a few months, or customers could be stuck waiting
until fall with the next release of the company's operating systems.

And there's a lot of improvement to be done in the market, whether for Siri
or its competition. In my view, virtual assistants should be automatic
companions that are able to provide you with all of the information that you
need and take care of daily inconveniences, while being available in high
quality form throughout the day on whatever computing platform you choose.
None of them are currently delivering on that promise.

For example, none of the assistants currently on the market can tell me when
the next Muni train will arrive at the station. San Francisco's transit
authority has an API for accessing information about trains' positions and
expected arrival times, and yet it's clear that integrating that information
isn't a priority for any of the companies building virtual assistants.

Even though Siri doesn't have the third-party integrations that Amazon's
Alexa does, it's hard for me to say that I'm really missing out on the
overwhelming majority of half-baked, minimally useful, or misguided skills
that clog up the Alexa store.

But while none are perfect, they're all critically important to the
companies that are producing them, which is why improvements to the HomePod
are a near-certainty. But until it gets better, I expect plenty of folks -
like me - will hold off purchasing one.

Original Article at:

The following information is important for all members of the V iPhone list.

If you have any questions or concerns about the running of this list, or if you 
feel that a member's post is inappropriate, please contact the owners or 
moderators directly rather than posting on the list itself.

Your V iPhone list moderator is Mark Taylor.  Mark can be reached at:  Your list owner is Cara Quinn - you can reach Cara at

The archives for this list can be searched at:
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"VIPhone" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
To post to this group, send email to
Visit this group at
For more options, visit

Reply via email to