Ryan, Thanks for your feedback!
See inline: On Tue, Jun 19, 2018 at 12:20:40PM -0700, Ryan Delgrosso wrote: > As you well know i have been working on a platform, and started off > using Kamailio as my edge proxy, but was pragmatically forced to pivot > to OpenSIPS as it could do more SBC-flavored things, which it seems > the Kamailio community find less than savory. Some and not others. > Of major note is the mid-registrar module, which allowed for short-re-reg > intervals on the outside for nat traversal, with long core intervals to > alleviate load, while also exposing a directly adjacent contact to the core > switch without the need for the core to support such esoteric measures as > the path header. This is crucial when supporting commercial registrars such > as broadsoft or a metaswitch (and to a lesser extent freeswitch which only > KINDA supports path) which are written expecting the commercial SBC behavior > of adjacent contacts. Indeed, and I made mention in the article. I have reason to believe Kamailio will have a comparable solution in the foreseeable future. > Abandoning SIP over UDP is a major topic for me these days. Once upon > a time SBC's were a great place to prune packets to limbo under the > 1500 byte MTU bar, but as we all know this is a losing battle with the > bloating of SDP's and the supported header, and can cause random > breakage. Furthermore with the internet at large becoming increasingly > hostile towards UDP as a transport due to the massive DDOS > possibilities many UDP protocols offer, the sip over udp client space > is becoming increasingly difficult. Moving access-side to TCP offers > literally nothing but upside, with one exception, failover, as you > well identified. Of course an open-source SBC in software carried with > it the possibility for automation and orchestration, and if you go > TCP, then there's literally no excuse to not encrypt everywhere and go > TLS with LetsEncrypt. TLS signaling also carries the benefit of > carving through ALG's and anti-competitive ISP practices. I don't think most of the ITSP industry has moved to that insight yet, although anecdotally, it appears that the metastasis of increasingly tenacious ALGs is creating a NAT support crisis. > Im still a proponent of UDP in the core, where jumbo-framing can be > guaranteed, as it allows for easier fail-over of core elements > mid-dialogue, and eliminates cumbersome state tracking inside a > trusted core. I would agree with that. -- Alex -- Alex Balashov | Principal | Evariste Systems LLC Tel: +1-706-510-6800 / +1-800-250-5920 (toll-free) Web: http://www.evaristesys.com/, http://www.csrpswitch.com/ _______________________________________________ VoiceOps mailing list [email protected] https://puck.nether.net/mailman/listinfo/voiceops
