Posted by Dale Carpenter:
Let's make a deal:
http://volokh.com/archives/archive_2009_03_08-2009_03_14.shtml#1236737313
At NRO's The Corner, [1]Maggie Gallagher notes that out-of-wedlock
birth rates in the U.S. have resumed their long-term rise, after a
period of flattening. And then she asks:
Is it mere coincidence that this resurgence in illegitimacy
happened during the five years in which gay marriage has become
(not thanks to me or my choice) the most prominent marriage issue
in America � and the one marriage idea endorsed by the tastemakers
to the young in particular?
On this view, not only does gay marriage contribute to heterosexual
irresponsibility, but even advocating gay marriage sets it off. This
is a lot to lay on a few gay couples in Massachusetts and a stack of
unread law review articles. Jon Rauch [2]responds that there's not
even a correlation here. There are multiple other problems, starting
with the arbitrariness and manipulability of the starting point (why
choose five years ago?). And note this: this resurgence in
illegitimacy happened during the five years in which gay marriage bans
have become (not thanks to me or my choice) the most prominent
marriage issue in America, and the one marriage idea emphasized by
"pro-family" conservatives to Americans, helping tar it as an
invidiously discriminatory institution.
But leave all that to one side. Here's my deal for Maggie: I'll admit
that "gay marriage," or I should say more precisely its "prominence"
among the trend-setting pointy-heads, contributed to more heterosexual
irresponsibility, circa 2003-08. In exchange, when illegitimacy
stabilizes or goes down, or when unmarried cohabitation falls off, or
when deadbeat dads start paying their child support, or when the rate
of second and third and fourth and umpteenth heterosexual marriages
declines, or when the traffic at [3]websites promoting adultery eases,
she will insinuate that gay marriage contributed to these trends too.
Deal?
References
1.
http://corner.nationalreview.com/post/?q=OWY3ODRhNDFjNzQ0Mzk0NDI2YjM4Y2YyOGVjMGVkNDU
2. http://indegayforum.com/blog/show/31744.html
3.
http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=NTQzYTQ3OGYzZmQ0ZmI4Yzg0NjMwZWUxMGVmZWUyNWY
_______________________________________________
Volokh mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.powerblogs.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/volokh
